Beijing Advanced Innovation Center for Biomedical Engineering, School of Biological Science and Medical Engineering, Beihang University, Beijing, China.
School of Medical Imaging, Shanxi Medical University, Taiyuan, China.
Med Phys. 2023 Jul;50(7):4351-4365. doi: 10.1002/mp.16233. Epub 2023 Feb 1.
Classifying the subtypes of non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) is essential for clinically adopting optimal treatment strategies and improving clinical outcomes, but the histological subtypes are confirmed by invasive biopsy or post-operative examination at present. Based on multi-center data, this study aimed to analyze the importance of extracted CT radiomics features and develop the model with good generalization performance for precisely distinguishing major NSCLC subtypes: adenocarcinoma (ADC) and squamous cell carcinoma (SCC).
We collected a multi-center CT dataset with 868 patients from eight international databases on the cancer imaging archive (TCIA). Among them, patients from five databases were mixed and split to training and test sets (560:140). The remaining three databases were used as independent test sets: TCGA set (n = 97) and lung3 set (n = 71). A total of 1409 features containing shape, intensity, and texture information were extracted from tumor volume of interest (VOI), then the ℓ -norm minimization was used for feature selection and the importance of selected features was analyzed. Next, the prediction and generalization performance of 130 radiomics models (10 common algorithms and 120 heterogeneous ensemble combinations) were compared by the average AUC value on three test sets. Finally, predictive results of the optimal model were shown.
After feature selection, 401 features were obtained. Features of intensity, texture GLCM, GLRLM, and GLSZM had higher classification weight coefficients than other features (shape, texture GLDM, and NGTDM), and the filtered image features exhibited significant importance than original image features (p-value = 0.0210). Moreover, five ensemble learning algorithms (Bagging, AdaBoost, RF, XGBoost, GBDT) had better generalization performance (p-value = 0.00418) than other non-ensemble algorithms (MLP, LR, GNB, SVM, KNN). The Bagging-AdaBoost-SVM model had the highest AUC value (0.815 ± 0.010) on three test sets. It obtained AUC values of 0.819, 0.823, and 0.804 on test set, TCGA set and lung3 set, respectively.
Our multi-dataset study showed that intensity features, texture features (GLCM, GLRLM, and GLSZM) and filtered image features were more important for distinguishing ADCs from SCCs. The method of ensemble learning can improve the prediction and generalization performance on the complicated multi-center data. The Bagging-AdaBoost-SVM model had the strongest generalization performance, and it showed promising clinical value for non-invasively predicting the histopathological subtypes of NSCLC.
对非小细胞肺癌(NSCLC)进行亚型分类对于临床采用最佳治疗策略和改善临床结局至关重要,但目前主要通过有创活检或术后检查来确定组织学亚型。基于多中心数据,本研究旨在分析提取 CT 放射组学特征的重要性,并开发具有良好泛化性能的模型,以准确区分 NSCLC 的主要亚型:腺癌(ADC)和鳞状细胞癌(SCC)。
我们从癌症影像档案(TCIA)上的八个国际数据库中收集了来自 868 名患者的多中心 CT 数据集。其中,来自五个数据库的患者被混合并分为训练集和测试集(560:140)。其余三个数据库被用作独立测试集:TCGA 集(n=97)和 lung3 集(n=71)。从肿瘤感兴趣区(VOI)中提取了包含形状、强度和纹理信息的 1409 个特征,然后使用 ℓ-范数最小化进行特征选择,并分析所选特征的重要性。接下来,通过三个测试集上的平均 AUC 值比较了 130 个放射组学模型(10 个常用算法和 120 个异构集成组合)的预测和泛化性能。最后,展示了最优模型的预测结果。
经过特征选择,得到 401 个特征。与其他特征(形状、纹理 GLDM 和 NGTDM)相比,强度、纹理 GLCM、GLRLM 和 GLSZM 特征的分类权重系数更高,过滤后的图像特征比原始图像特征更重要(p 值=0.0210)。此外,五种集成学习算法(Bagging、AdaBoost、RF、XGBoost、GBDT)的泛化性能(p 值=0.00418)优于其他非集成算法(MLP、LR、GNB、SVM、KNN)。Bagging-AdaBoost-SVM 模型在三个测试集上的 AUC 值最高(0.815±0.010)。在测试集、TCGA 集和 lung3 集上,它分别获得了 0.819、0.823 和 0.804 的 AUC 值。
我们的多数据集研究表明,对于区分 ADC 和 SCC,强度特征、纹理特征(GLCM、GLRLM 和 GLSZM)和过滤后的图像特征更为重要。集成学习方法可以提高对复杂多中心数据的预测和泛化性能。Bagging-AdaBoost-SVM 模型具有最强的泛化性能,它在非侵入性预测 NSCLC 的组织病理学亚型方面具有有前景的临床价值。