Department of Chronic Disease Epidemiology, Yale School of Public Health, Yale School of Medicine, 60 College Street, New Haven, CT 06510, USA.
Department of Psychiatry, Yale School of Medicine, CMHC, 34 Park Street, New Haven, CT 06519, USA.
Addict Behav. 2023 Aug;143:107710. doi: 10.1016/j.addbeh.2023.107710. Epub 2023 Mar 30.
Empirical evidence about the effectiveness of using e-cigarettes to quit smoking cigarettes remains inconclusive, yet e-cigarettes are commonly used for smoking cessation. Moreover, people who have longer duration quit attempts are likely to have even longer quit attempts in the future. Researchers analyzed 40 qualitative interviews to assess adults' experiences using e-cigarettes during their longest duration quit attempt. Interviewees quit smoking for ≥ one month (n = 20) or for shorter durations (n = 20). Thematic and comparative content analyses were used to analyze interview transcripts for factors facilitating or impeding the duration of quit attempts when using e-cigarettes. Participant narratives were mostly similar irrespective of their quit attempt duration. Six themes common across groups as well as themes more often discussed by people with shorter quit attempts are described. Most participants discussed using e-cigarette devices and flavors to either replace sensations similar to smoking combustible cigarettes (e.g., inhaling from a cylindrical object) or to distract themselves from cravings to smoke. E-cigarettes also were described by the majority of participants as useful for smoking cessation because they approximate combustible cigarette use, potentially reduce health-related harms, save money, and lead to reduced social stigma compared to smoking cigarettes. Those who reported shorter duration quit attempts shared e-cigarette product challenges, health concerns, needs for support. Study findings demonstrate the need for additional research on the factors that may increase the likelihood that using e-cigarettes will result in longer and sustained e-cigarette-based quit attempts among adults.
关于使用电子烟戒烟的有效性的经验证据仍不明确,但电子烟常被用于戒烟。此外,尝试戒烟时间较长的人未来可能会有更长的戒烟尝试。研究人员分析了 40 份定性访谈,以评估成年人在最长戒烟尝试期间使用电子烟的经验。受访者戒烟时间 ≥1 个月(n=20)或更短时间(n=20)。使用主题和对比内容分析法分析访谈记录,以确定在使用电子烟时促进或阻碍戒烟尝试持续时间的因素。无论其戒烟尝试持续时间如何,参与者的叙述大多相似。描述了六个常见于两个组的主题以及在戒烟尝试时间较短的人中更常讨论的主题。大多数参与者讨论了使用电子烟设备和口味来替代与吸可燃香烟相似的感觉(例如,从圆柱形物体吸入)或分散对吸烟的渴望。大多数参与者还将电子烟描述为戒烟的有效方法,因为它们近似于可燃香烟的使用,可能会减少与健康相关的危害,节省金钱,并与吸烟相比减少社会污名化。那些报告戒烟尝试时间较短的人分享了电子烟产品挑战、健康问题、支持需求。研究结果表明,需要进一步研究可能增加使用电子烟导致成年人更长和持续的电子烟戒烟尝试的可能性的因素。