Department of Obstetrics & Gynecology, Medical University of Graz, Austria.
Department of Obstetrics & Gynecology, Medical University of Graz, Austria.
Eur J Obstet Gynecol Reprod Biol. 2023 Jun;285:81-85. doi: 10.1016/j.ejogrb.2023.03.043. Epub 2023 Apr 6.
Enhanced recovery after surgery (ERAS) recommendations for cesarean section (ERAC), likely the most common reason for laparotomy in women, were issued in 2018-19. We examined how current perioperative management at cesarean section in Austrian hospitals aligns with ERAS recommendations.
We surveyed the 21 largest public obstetric units in Austria for alignment with 20 of the 31 strong ERAS recommendations regarding perioperative maternal care at cesarean section. We also looked at how the German-language clinical guideline for cesarean section (AWMF Guideline Sectio caesarea) aligns with ERAS recommendations.
The 21 obstetric units cared for about 51% of all births in Austria in 2019. Cesarean section rates ranged from 17.7% to 50.4%. All 21 units implemented the five strong recommendations regarding patient information and counselling, regional anesthesia, euvolemia and multimodal analgesia. The least implemented strong recommendation was the one for the use of pneumatic compression stockings to prevent thromboembolic disease (0/21 units). Overall, all 21 units implemented ≥11 and 13 (62%) implemented ≥15 (≥75%) of the 20 strong recommendations; no unit implemented all 20 strong recommendations. There were no differences in the implementation of strong recommendations according to hospital volume.
Even in the absence of formal adoption of ERAS program for cesarean section many perioperative ERAS recommendations are already implemented in Austria. The least implemented recommendations were the use of pneumatic compression stockings (0 of 21 units) and immediate catheter removal (4 of 21 units). Only 10 of the 20 ERAS recommendations we looked at are included in the current German-language clinical guideline for cesarean section.
增强手术后康复(ERAS)建议被用于剖宫产(ERAC),这可能是女性最常见的剖腹手术原因。我们研究了奥地利医院目前的剖宫产围手术期管理与 ERAS 建议的吻合程度。
我们对奥地利 21 家最大的公立产科单位进行了调查,以了解 31 项 ERAS 强烈建议中关于剖宫产围手术期产妇护理的 20 项建议的吻合程度。我们还研究了德语剖宫产临床指南(AWMF Guideline Sectio caesarea)与 ERAS 建议的吻合程度。
21 家产科单位在 2019 年照顾了奥地利约 51%的分娩。剖宫产率从 17.7%到 50.4%不等。所有 21 家单位都实施了 5 项关于患者信息和咨询、区域麻醉、血容量正常和多模式镇痛的强烈建议。实施最少的强烈建议是使用气动压缩袜预防血栓栓塞性疾病(21 家单位中没有一家)。总体而言,所有 21 家单位都实施了 20 项强烈建议中的≥11 项和 13 项(≥75%);没有一家单位实施了所有 20 项强烈建议。根据医院容量,强烈建议的实施情况没有差异。
即使没有正式采用 ERAS 剖宫产计划,许多围手术期 ERAS 建议在奥地利已经得到实施。实施最少的建议是使用气动压缩袜(21 家单位中没有一家)和立即去除导尿管(21 家单位中只有 4 家)。我们研究的 20 项 ERAS 建议中只有 10 项包含在当前的德语剖宫产临床指南中。