Department of Pharmacy Practice, Shifa College of Pharmaceutical Sciences, Shifa Tameer-e-Millat University, Islamabad, Pakistan.
University of Houston, Houston, TX, USA.
Antimicrob Resist Infect Control. 2023 Nov 23;12(1):132. doi: 10.1186/s13756-023-01311-2.
Antibiotics have helped to reduce the incidence of common infectious diseases in all modern healthcare systems, but improper use of antibiotics including their overuse and misuse can change the bacteria so much that antibiotics don't work against them. In case of developing imposable selective pressure with regard to the proportion of hospitalized patients who receive antibiotics, the quantity of antibiotics that are prescribed to them, and the proportion of patients who receive antibiotic treatment is one of the major contributors to the rising global health issue of antimicrobial resistance. Concerning the levels of antibiotic consumption in Pakistani hospitals, there is negligible research data available.
This study aimed to evaluate five-year inpatient antibiotic use in a tertiary care hospital in Islamabad using the World Health Organization (WHO) Recommended Anatomical Therapeutic Chemical (ATC) Classification / Defined Daily Dose (DDD) methodology.
It was a descriptive study involving a retrospective record review of pharmacy records of antibiotics dispensed (amount in grams) to patients across different specialties of the hospital from January 2017 to December 2021 (i.e., 60 consecutive months). The antibiotic consumption was calculated by using the DDD/100-Bed Days (BDs) formula, and then relative percent change was estimated using Microsoft Excel 2021 edition.
A total of 148,483 (77%) patients who received antibiotics were included in the study out of 193,436 patients admitted in the hospital. Antibiotic consumption trends showed considerable fluctuations over a five-year period. It kept on declining irregularly from 2017 to 2019, inclined vigorously in 2020, and then suddenly dropped to the lowest DDD/100 BDs value (96.02) in the last year of the study. The overall percentage of encounters in which antibiotics were prescribed at tertiary care hospital was 77% which is very high compared to the WHO standard reference value (< 30%). WATCH group antibiotics were prescribed (76%) and consumed more within inpatient settings than Access (12%) and Reserve (12%) antibiotics.
The hospital antibiotic consumption data is well maintained across different inpatient specialties but it is largely non-aligned with WHO AWaRe (Access-Watch-Reserve) antibiotics use and optimization during 2017-2021. Compared to the WHO standard reference figure, the overall percentage of antibiotics encountered was higher by about 47%. Antibiotic consumption trends vary with a slight increase in hospital occupancy rate, with positive relative changes being lower in number but higher in proportion than negative changes. Although the hospital antibiotics policy is in place but seems not to be followed with a high degree of adherence.
抗生素的使用帮助降低了所有现代医疗体系中常见传染病的发病率,但抗生素的使用不当,包括过度使用和滥用,会导致细菌发生很大变化,从而使抗生素对其失去作用。如果住院患者接受抗生素治疗的比例、处方给他们的抗生素数量以及接受抗生素治疗的患者比例方面出现不可避免的选择压力,这将成为全球抗生素耐药性问题日益严重的主要原因之一。关于巴基斯坦医院的抗生素使用水平,几乎没有可用的研究数据。
本研究旨在使用世界卫生组织(WHO)推荐的解剖学治疗化学(ATC)分类/限定日剂量(DDD)方法,评估伊斯兰堡一家三级保健医院五年的住院患者抗生素使用情况。
这是一项描述性研究,回顾性分析了 2017 年 1 月至 2021 年 12 月(即 60 个月)期间医院不同科室患者的药房记录中开具的抗生素(克数)。使用 DDD/100 床位日(BDs)公式计算抗生素使用量,然后使用 Microsoft Excel 2021 版估计相对百分比变化。
在该医院收治的 193436 名患者中,共有 148483 名(77%)接受抗生素治疗的患者纳入研究。五年期间,抗生素使用趋势波动较大。从 2017 年到 2019 年,抗生素使用量不规则下降,2020 年急剧上升,然后在研究的最后一年突然降至最低 DDD/100 BDs 值(96.02)。在三级保健医院,开处方的就诊比例为 77%,远高于世卫组织的标准参考值(<30%)。WATCH 组抗生素(76%)在住院环境中的使用和消耗均高于 Access(12%)和 Reserve(12%)抗生素。
该医院不同住院科室的抗生素使用数据保存良好,但在 2017-2021 年期间,抗生素的使用与世卫组织 AWaRe(Access-Watch-Reserve)抗生素的使用和优化标准基本不符。与世卫组织的标准参考数据相比,抗生素的总使用比例高出约 47%。抗生素使用趋势随医院入住率的轻微增加而变化,正相关变化的数量虽少,但比例却高于负相关变化。尽管医院有抗生素使用政策,但似乎并没有得到高度遵守。