Browning Christopher R, Tarrence Jake, Calder Catherine A, Pinchak Nicolo P, Boettner Bethany
The Ohio State University.
The University of Texas at Austin.
AJS. 2022 Nov;128(3):914-961. doi: 10.1086/721666.
Foundational urban social theories view heterogeneity of exposure to spatial and social contexts as essential aspects of the urban experience. In contrast, contemporary neighborhood research emphasizes the isolation of city dwellers - particularly residents of racially segregated neighborhoods. Using geospatial data on a sample of youth from the 2014-16 Columbus, OH-based study, we explore the extent to which the neighborhood locations of everyday activities vary with respect to residential racial composition. In the context of segregated US metro areas, the approach expects home census tract racial composition to powerfully shape the racial composition of activity location neighborhoods. In this view, Black youth residing in high proportion Black neighborhoods are expected to spend the vast majority of their time exposed to similarly Black-concentrated neighborhoods. Consistent with an alternative approach, we find that Black youth residing in high proportion Black neighborhoods exhibit among the highest levels of heterogeneity in the racial composition of neighborhoods encountered. Moreover, Black youth residing in high proportion Black neighborhoods are expected to spend 39% of their non-home time (roughly 2.5 hours a day) in low proportion Black neighborhoods compared to 23% (1.5 hours) in high proportion Black neighborhoods. Exposures to low proportion Black neighborhoods among these youth are largely driven by organizationally-based resource seeking. These findings call into question the assumption that residence in Black segregated neighborhoods leads to homogeneously Black segregated neighborhood exposures and encourage theoretical development and data collection strategies that acknowledge the potential for significant heterogeneity in the everyday neighborhood experiences of urban youth.
基础城市社会理论将接触空间和社会环境的异质性视为城市体验的基本方面。相比之下,当代社区研究强调城市居民的隔离——尤其是居住在种族隔离社区的居民。利用2014 - 16年俄亥俄州哥伦布市一项针对青年样本的地理空间数据,我们探讨了日常活动的社区位置在居住种族构成方面的差异程度。在美国大都市地区隔离的背景下,该方法预计家庭普查区的种族构成会有力地塑造活动地点社区的种族构成。按照这种观点,居住在黑人比例高的社区的黑人青年预计大部分时间都处于黑人同样集中的社区。与另一种方法一致,我们发现居住在黑人比例高的社区的黑人青年在遇到的社区种族构成方面表现出最高水平的异质性。此外,居住在黑人比例高的社区的黑人青年预计其非家庭时间的39%(约每天2.5小时)会在黑人比例低的社区度过,而在黑人比例高的社区这一比例为23%(1.5小时)。这些青年接触黑人比例低的社区很大程度上是由基于组织的资源寻求驱动的。这些发现质疑了居住在黑人隔离社区会导致清一色的黑人隔离社区接触的假设,并鼓励理论发展和数据收集策略,承认城市青年日常社区体验中存在显著异质性的可能性。