Rawcliffe Alex J, Tyson Hayley, Hinde Katrina, Jacka Kimberley, Holland Rachel, Chapman Shaun, Roberts Andrew J
Army Recruit Health and Performance Research, Medical Branch, HQ Army Recruiting and Initial Training Command, Ministry of Defence, Upavon, United Kingdom.
Faculty of Science and Engineering, Anglia Ruskin University, Cambridge, United Kingdom.
Front Neurol. 2024 Feb 14;15:1321032. doi: 10.3389/fneur.2024.1321032. eCollection 2024.
Sleep is critical to the health, wellbeing and performance of military personnel during basic training. This two-part study evaluated sleep-wake patterns and sleep disturbances in junior soldiers (JS) and infantry recruits in Autumn 2021 (study 1), and non-infantry recruits in spring 2022 (study 2).
During studies 1 and 2, validated wearable technology combined with a sleep diary was used to quantify sleep-wake indices, sleep disturbances and perceptions of sleep quality. Sleep diary data was analysed descriptively. A series of repeated-measures ANOVAs examined differences in objective sleep-wake indices. Correlation analysis determined associations between time in bed (TIB) and total sleep time (TST).
Significant ( < 0.05) differences in most sleep-wake indices were observed between weeks of basic training for all cohorts. Strong positive correlations between TIB and TST were observed for each cohort across basic training ( = 0.681 - 0.970, < 0.001), with longer TST associated with greater TIB. The mean±SD sleep duration (hours and mins [hm]) for JS (06:22 ± 00:27hm), non-infantry (05:41 ± 00:47hm) and infantry (05:46 ± 00:34hm) recruits across basic training was consistently below national recommendations. The mean±SD bed and wake times for JS (bedtime: 23:01 ± 00:32hm; awake: 05:34 ± 00:10hm), non-infantry (bedtime: 23:38 ± 01:09hm; awake: 04:47 ± 00:58hm), and infantry (bedtime: 23:13 ± 00:29hm; awake: 05:38 ± 00:26hm) recruits varied across weeks of basic training, with over 80% reporting "fairly bad" or "very bad" sleep quality and frequent periods of "dozing off" during daytime activity. The most commonly reported sleep disturbing factors identified during basic training involved: late-night military admin (e.g., ironing, boot cleaning, kit set up etc), early morning wake times, extraneous noise, light and hot room temperatures within the primary sleeping environment, bed/mattress discomfort, muscle soreness and feelings of stress and anxiety.
DISCUSSION/CONCLUSION: Our findings contribute to the existing evidence that long-term sleep loss is pervasive during initial military training programmes. The average sleep durations indicate chronic and unrecoverable sleep loss which would be expected to significantly impair physical and cognitive military performance, and increase the risk of injury, illness and attrition rates during basic training. Changes in the design and scheduling of basic training programmes to enable, at the least, minimum sleep recommendations to be met, and to improve sleep hygiene in the primary sleeping environment are warranted.
睡眠对于军事人员在基础训练期间的健康、福祉和表现至关重要。这项分为两部分的研究评估了2021年秋季初级士兵(JS)和步兵新兵的睡眠-觉醒模式及睡眠障碍(研究1),以及2022年春季非步兵新兵的睡眠-觉醒模式及睡眠障碍(研究2)。
在研究1和研究2期间,使用经过验证的可穿戴技术结合睡眠日记来量化睡眠-觉醒指标、睡眠障碍和睡眠质量感知。对睡眠日记数据进行描述性分析。一系列重复测量方差分析检验了客观睡眠-觉醒指标的差异。相关分析确定了卧床时间(TIB)与总睡眠时间(TST)之间的关联。
在所有队列的基础训练周之间,大多数睡眠-觉醒指标存在显著(<0.05)差异。在基础训练期间,每个队列的TIB和TST之间均观察到强正相关(=0.681 - 0.970,<0.001),TST越长,TIB越长。基础训练期间,JS新兵(06:22±00:27小时分钟[hm])、非步兵新兵(05:41±00:47hm)和步兵新兵(05:46±00:34hm)的平均±标准差睡眠时间(小时和分钟[hm])一直低于国家建议值。JS新兵(就寝时间:23:01±00:32hm;起床时间:05:34±00:10hm)、非步兵新兵(就寝时间:23:38±01:09hm;起床时间:04:47±00:58hm)和步兵新兵(就寝时间:23:13±00:29hm;起床时间:05:38±00:26hm)的平均±标准差就寝和起床时间在基础训练周期间有所不同,超过80%的人报告睡眠质量“相当差”或“非常差”,并且在白天活动期间经常“打瞌睡”。在基础训练期间最常报告的睡眠干扰因素包括:深夜军事管理事务(如熨烫、擦靴子、整理装备等)、清晨起床时间、外部噪音、主要睡眠环境中的光线和高温、床/床垫不适、肌肉酸痛以及压力和焦虑感。
讨论/结论:我们的研究结果为现有证据提供了补充,即长期睡眠不足在初始军事训练计划中普遍存在。平均睡眠时间表明存在慢性且无法恢复的睡眠不足,预计这将显著损害身体和认知军事表现,并增加基础训练期间受伤、患病和损耗率的风险。有必要改变基础训练计划的设计和安排,至少要满足最低睡眠建议,并改善主要睡眠环境中的睡眠卫生。