Department of Orthopaedics and Musculoskeletal Science, University College London, London, United Kingdom.
Therapies and Department of Orthopaedic Oncology, London Sarcoma Service, Royal National Orthopaedic Hospital NHS Trust, Stanmore, United Kingdom.
PLoS One. 2024 Mar 28;19(3):e0300351. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0300351. eCollection 2024.
Physical limitations are frequent and debilitating after sarcoma treatment. Markerless motion capture (MMC) could measure these limitations. Historically expensive cumbersome systems have posed barriers to clinical translation.
Can inexpensive MMC [using Microsoft KinectTM] assess functional outcomes after sarcoma surgery, discriminate between tumour sub-groups and agree with existing assessments?
Walking, unilateral stance and kneeling were measured in a cross-sectional study of patients with lower extremity sarcomas using MMC and standard video. Summary measures of temporal, balance, gait and movement velocity were derived. Feasibility and early indicators of validity of MMC were explored by comparing MMC measures i) between tumour sub-groups; ii) against video and iii) with established sarcoma tools [Toronto Extremity Salvage Score (TESS)), Musculoskeletal Tumour Rating System (MSTS), Quality of life-cancer survivors (QoL-CS)]. Statistical analysis was conducted using SPSS v19. Tumour sub-groups were compared using Mann-Whitney U tests, MMC was compared to existing sarcoma measures using correlations and with video using Intraclass correlation coefficient agreement.
Thirty-four adults of mean age 43 (minimum value-maximum value 19-89) years with musculoskeletal tumours in the femur (19), pelvis/hip (3), tibia (9), or ankle/foot (3) participated; 27 had limb sparing surgery and 7 amputation. MMC was well-tolerated and feasible to deliver. MMC discriminated between surgery groups for balance (p<0.05*), agreed with video for kneeling times [ICC = 0.742; p = 0.001*] and showed moderate relationships between MSTS and gait (p = 0.022*, r = -0.416); TESS and temporal outcomes (p = 0.016* and r = -0.0557*), movement velocity (p = 0.021*, r = -0.541); QoL-CS and balance (p = 0.027*, r = 0.441) [* = statistical significance]. As MMC uncovered important relationships between outcomes, it gave an insight into how functional impairments, balance, gait, disabilities and quality of life (QoL) are associated with each other. This gives an insight into mechanisms of poor outcomes, producing clinically useful data i.e. data which can inform clinical practice and guide the delivery of targeted rehabilitation. For example, patients presenting with poor balance in various activities can be prescribed with balance rehabilitation and those with difficulty in movements or activity transitions can be managed with exercises and training to improve the quality and efficiency of the movement.
In this first study world-wide, investigating the use of MMC after sarcoma surgery, MMC was found to be acceptable and feasible to assess functional outcomes in this cancer population. MMC demonstrated early indicators of validity and also provided new knowledge that functional impairments are related to balance during unilateral stance and kneeling, gait and movement velocity during kneeling and these outcomes in turn are related to disabilities and QoL. This highlighted important relationships between different functional outcomes and QoL, providing valuable information for delivering personalised rehabilitation. After completing future validation work in a larger study, this approach can offer promise in clinical settings. Low-cost MMC shows promise in assessing patient's impairments in the hospitals or their homes and guiding clinical management and targeted rehabilitation based on novel MMC outcomes affected, therefore providing an opportunity for delivering personalised exercise programmes and physiotherapy care delivery for this rare cancer.
肉瘤治疗后常出现身体机能受限,且这些受限往往使人虚弱。无标记运动捕捉(MMC)可测量这些受限。但过去昂贵且笨重的系统对临床转化构成了障碍。
使用价格低廉的 MMC(采用微软 KinectTM)能否评估肉瘤手术后的功能结果,能否区分肿瘤亚组,以及与现有评估方法是否一致?
使用 MMC 和标准视频对下肢肉瘤患者进行横断面研究,测量步行、单腿站立和单膝跪地的情况。从时间、平衡、步态和运动速度等方面得出综合测量指标。通过比较肿瘤亚组之间的 MMC 测量值,以及与视频和现有的肉瘤评估工具(多伦多肢体挽救评分(TESS)、肌肉骨骼肿瘤评分系统(MSTS)、癌症幸存者生活质量(QoL-CS))的比较,探讨 MMC 的可行性和早期有效性指标。使用 SPSS v19 进行统计分析。使用 Mann-Whitney U 检验比较肿瘤亚组,使用相关性比较 MMC 与现有的肉瘤评估工具,使用组内相关系数(ICC)一致性比较与视频。
34 名成年人参与了这项研究,平均年龄为 43 岁(最小值-最大值 19-89 岁),患有股骨(19 例)、骨盆/臀部(3 例)、胫骨(9 例)或踝/足部(3 例)的肌肉骨骼肿瘤;27 例接受保肢手术,7 例接受截肢。MMC 耐受性良好,实施可行。MMC 可区分手术组的平衡能力(p<0.05*),与视频比较,MMC 对单膝跪地时间的测量结果具有一致性[ICC=0.742;p=0.001*],与 MSTS 和步态之间具有中度相关性(p=0.022*,r=-0.416);与 TESS 和时间结局(p=0.016和 r=-0.0557)、运动速度(p=0.021*,r=-0.541);与 QoL-CS 和平衡(p=0.027*,r=0.441)[*=统计学意义]。由于 MMC 揭示了功能障碍、平衡、步态、残疾和生活质量(QoL)之间的重要关系,它深入了解了这些功能障碍如何相互关联。这深入了解了不良结局的机制,提供了有临床意义的数据,即可以为临床实践提供信息并指导靶向康复的实施的数据。例如,对于在各种活动中表现出平衡能力差的患者,可以开具平衡康复处方;对于运动或活动转换困难的患者,可以通过锻炼和训练来管理,以提高运动的质量和效率。
在这项全球范围内首次研究中,研究了 MMC 在肉瘤手术后的应用,发现 MMC 可用于评估该癌症人群的功能结果,且接受度和实施性良好。MMC 表现出早期有效性的迹象,并提供了新的知识,即功能障碍与单腿站立和单膝跪地时的平衡、单膝跪地时的步态和运动速度有关,这些结果反过来又与残疾和 QoL 有关。这强调了不同功能结果和 QoL 之间的重要关系,为提供个性化康复提供了有价值的信息。在未来更大规模的验证研究完成后,这种方法有望在临床环境中得到应用。价格低廉的 MMC 有望在医院或家中评估患者的损伤情况,并指导临床管理和基于新型 MMC 结果的靶向康复,从而为提供个性化的运动方案和物理治疗护理提供机会,从而为这种罕见的癌症提供个性化的治疗。