Department of Urban and Environmental Policy and Planning, Tufts University, Medford, MA, USA.
Department of Public Health and Community Medicine, Tufts University School of Medicine, Boston, MA, USA.
BMC Public Health. 2024 Jul 15;24(1):1893. doi: 10.1186/s12889-024-19399-5.
Fatal opioid-involved overdose rates increased precipitously from 5.0 per 100,000 population to 33.5 in Massachusetts between 1999 and 2022.
We used spatial rate smoothing techniques to identify persistent opioid overdose-involved fatality clusters at the ZIP Code Tabulation Area (ZCTA) level. Rate smoothing techniques were employed to identify locations of high fatal opioid overdose rates where population counts were low. In Massachusetts, this included areas with both sparse data and low population density. We used Local Indicators of Spatial Association (LISA) cluster analyses with the raw incidence rates, and the Empirical Bayes smoothed rates to identify clusters from 2011 to 2021. We also estimated Empirical Bayes LISA cluster estimates to identify clusters during the same period. We constructed measures of the socio-built environment and potentially inappropriate prescribing using principal components analysis. The resulting measures were used as covariates in Conditional Autoregressive Bayesian models that acknowledge spatial autocorrelation to predict both, if a ZCTA was part of an opioid-involved cluster for fatal overdose rates, as well as the number of times that it was part of a cluster of high incidence rates.
LISA clusters for smoothed data were able to identify whether a ZCTA was part of a opioid involved fatality incidence cluster earlier in the study period, when compared to LISA clusters based on raw rates. PCA helped in identifying unique socio-environmental factors, such as minoritized populations and poverty, potentially inappropriate prescribing, access to amenities, and rurality by combining socioeconomic, built environment and prescription variables that were highly correlated with each other. In all models except for those that used raw rates to estimate whether a ZCTA was part of a high fatality cluster, opioid overdose fatality clusters in Massachusetts had high percentages of Black and Hispanic residents, and households experiencing poverty. The models that were fitted on Empirical Bayes LISA identified this phenomenon earlier in the study period than the raw rate LISA. However, all the models identified minoritized populations and poverty as significant factors in predicting the persistence of a ZCTA being part of a high opioid overdose cluster during this time period.
Conducting spatially robust analyses may help inform policies to identify community-level risks for opioid-involved overdose deaths sooner than depending on raw incidence rates alone. The results can help inform policy makers and planners about locations of persistent risk.
1999 年至 2022 年间,马萨诸塞州的致命阿片类药物过量死亡率从每 10 万人 5.0 例急剧上升至 33.5 例。
我们使用空间率平滑技术来识别 ZCTA 层面持续存在的阿片类药物过量致死的簇。率平滑技术用于识别人口计数低但致命阿片类药物过量率高的位置。在马萨诸塞州,这包括数据稀疏和人口密度低的地区。我们使用原始发病率的局部指标空间关联(LISA)聚类分析,以及经验贝叶斯平滑率来识别 2011 年至 2021 年的簇。我们还估计了同期经验贝叶斯 LISA 聚类估计数。我们使用主成分分析构建社会建设环境和潜在不适当处方的度量。将得到的度量用作条件自回归贝叶斯模型的协变量,以承认空间自相关,从而预测 ZCTA 是否是致命阿片类药物过量死亡率的簇的一部分,以及它是否是高发病率簇的一部分的次数。
与基于原始率的 LISA 聚类相比,平滑数据的 LISA 聚类能够更早地识别 ZCTA 是否是研究期间阿片类药物相关死亡率的簇的一部分。PCA 有助于通过组合高度相关的社会经济、建筑环境和处方变量来识别独特的社会环境因素,如少数民族人口和贫困、潜在不适当的处方、获得设施和农村地区。除了使用原始率来估计 ZCTA 是否是高死亡率簇的一部分的模型外,在所有模型中,马萨诸塞州的阿片类药物过量死亡率簇都有很高比例的黑人和西班牙裔居民,以及贫困家庭。在这个研究期间,基于经验贝叶斯 LISA 拟合的模型比原始率 LISA 更早地识别出这一现象。然而,所有模型都将少数民族人口和贫困确定为预测 ZCTA 在这一时期成为高阿片类药物过量簇的一部分的持续存在的重要因素。
进行空间稳健分析可能有助于识别社区层面的阿片类药物过量死亡风险,而不仅仅依赖于原始发病率。结果可以帮助决策者和规划者了解持续存在风险的地点。