Bunaciu Adela, Bliuc Ana-Maria, Best David, Hennessy Emily A, Belanger Matthew, Benwell Christopher
Department of Psychology, School of Humanities, Social Science and Law, University of Dundee, Dundee, United Kingdom.
Centre for Addiction Recovery Research, Leeds Trinity University.
Addict Res Theory. 2024;32(3):225-236. doi: 10.1080/16066359.2023.2245323. Epub 2023 Aug 18.
Recovery capital theory provides a biopsychosocial framework for identifying and measuring strengths and barriers that can be targeted to support recovery from alcohol and drug addiction. This systematic review analyzed and synthesized all quantitative approaches that have measured recovery capital since 2016.
Three databases were searched to identify studies published from 2016 to 2023. Eligible studies explicitly stated they measured recovery capital in participants recovering from alcohol and/or drug addiction. Studies focusing on other forms of addiction were excluded.
Sixty-nine studies met the inclusion criteria. Forty-six studies used one of the ten identified recovery capital questionnaires, and twenty-five studies used a measurement approach other than one of the ten recovery capital questionnaires. The ten recovery capital questionnaires are primarily developed for adult populations across clinical and community recovery settings, and between them measure 41 separate recovery capital constructs. They are generally considered valid and reliable measures of recovery capital. Nevertheless, a strong evidence base on the psychometric properties across diverse populations and settings still needs to be established for these questionnaires.
The development of recovery capital questionnaires has been a significant advance in the field of addiction recovery, in alignment with the emerging recovery-oriented approach to addiction recovery care. Additionally, the non-recovery capital questionnaire-based approaches to recovery capital measurement have an important place in the field. They could be used alongside recovery capital questionnaires to test theory, and in contexts where the application of the questionnaires is not feasible, such as analyses of data from online recovery forums.
康复资本理论提供了一个生物心理社会框架,用于识别和衡量有助于酒精和药物成瘾康复的优势和障碍。本系统评价分析并综合了自2016年以来所有测量康复资本的定量方法。
检索了三个数据库,以识别2016年至2023年发表的研究。符合条件的研究明确表示,它们测量了从酒精和/或药物成瘾中康复的参与者的康复资本。排除了关注其他成瘾形式的研究。
69项研究符合纳入标准。46项研究使用了十种已识别的康复资本问卷中的一种,25项研究使用了十种康复资本问卷之外的测量方法。这十种康复资本问卷主要是为临床和社区康复环境中的成年人群开发的,它们总共测量了41个不同的康复资本构成要素。它们通常被认为是康复资本的有效和可靠测量方法。然而,对于这些问卷在不同人群和环境中的心理测量特性,仍需要建立强有力的证据基础。
康复资本问卷的开发是成瘾康复领域的一项重大进展,与新兴的以康复为导向的成瘾康复护理方法相一致。此外,基于非康复资本问卷的康复资本测量方法在该领域也占有重要地位。它们可以与康复资本问卷一起使用来检验理论,并且在问卷应用不可行的情况下,例如对在线康复论坛数据的分析中使用。