Elhariry Maiar, Iyer Pranav, Isack Nadya, Sousa Bernado, Singh Pushpa, Abbott Sally, Wiggins Tom, Nirantharakumar Krishnarajah, Bellary Srikanth, Flint Stuart W, Pournaras Dimitri J, Hazlehurst Jonathan M
College of Medical and Dental Sciences, University of Birmingham, Birmingham, UK.
Obesity Empowerment Network, UK.
Clin Obes. 2025 Jun;15(3):e12731. doi: 10.1111/cob.12731. Epub 2025 Jan 19.
Specialist weight management services including bariatric surgery are commissioned within regions of England called Integrated Care Systems (ICSs) with eligibility and treatment guidelines determined as part of the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) guidance. Reported variation in commissioning and bariatric surgery eligibility criteria has not been previously mapped. Freedom of Information (FOI) requests provide a tool, supported by legislation, to ask questions of public authorities including ICSs such that they must respond accurately. FOIs were sent to all 42 ICSs in England asking 4 questions aiming to establish whether there is variation in the commissioning of specialist weight management services and the eligibility criteria for bariatric surgery across England. Responses were presented descriptively and mapped across England. Responses were received from 41 out of 42 ICSs, with 34 reporting that they provide commissioned medical weight management programmes and 38 funding bariatric surgery. Thirteen reported using criteria that were not compliant with NICE guidance. A large area of the country centred around the East of England does not have a bariatric unit reducing access to care. There is significant geographical variation in the availability of both bariatric and specialist medical weight management services across England, with large portions of the country without local access to a service or no service at all. Where services are available, there is significant inconsistency in eligibility for bariatric surgery despite nationally available guidance.
包括减肥手术在内的专科体重管理服务在英格兰称为综合医疗系统(ICSs)的地区提供,其资格和治疗指南是作为国家卫生与临床优化研究所(NICE)指南的一部分确定的。此前尚未对已报告的委托安排和减肥手术资格标准的差异进行梳理。信息自由(FOI)请求提供了一种在法律支持下的工具,用于向包括ICSs在内的公共当局提问,以便它们必须准确回应。向英格兰所有42个ICSs发送了信息自由请求,询问4个问题,旨在确定英格兰各地专科体重管理服务的委托安排和减肥手术资格标准是否存在差异。对回复进行了描述性呈现并在英格兰各地进行了梳理。42个ICSs中有41个回复,其中34个报告称他们提供委托的医学体重管理项目,38个为减肥手术提供资金。13个报告称使用的标准不符合NICE指南。以英格兰东部为中心的该国大片地区没有减肥手术科室,减少了获得护理的机会。英格兰各地减肥和专科医学体重管理服务的可及性存在显著的地理差异,该国很大一部分地区无法在当地获得服务或根本没有服务。在有服务的地方,尽管有全国通用的指南,但减肥手术的资格标准存在显著不一致。