Mansfield Michael, Jong Stephanie T, Smith Toby
Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences, University of East Anglia, Norwich, United Kingdom.
School of Sport, Exercise and Rehabilitation Sciences, College of Life and Environmental Sciences, University of Birmingham, Birmingham, United Kingdom.
PLoS One. 2025 Jul 2;20(7):e0325922. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0325922. eCollection 2025.
Cervical spine radiculopathy [CSR] is a complex condition that is challenging to diagnose. The assessment methods used by United Kingdom [UK] physiotherapists to diagnose CSR remain unclear. A mixed-methods explanatory sequential design was used to investigate the assessment strategies that UK Health and Care Professions Council HCPC physiotherapists use and the reasons behind this decision-making in clinical practice. Phase 1 of the mixed methods research [MMR] study was a national online survey. The 63 respondents reported that the most common assessment strategies included muscle strength [94%], light touch sensation [78%] and reflex testing [89%]. Phase 2 of the MMR study included 11 qualitative interviews with Phase 1 [survey] participants. Four themes were established: perception of role, service constraints, minimising risk, and understanding symptoms. Physiotherapists often explained decision making in practice is based upon individual and organisational barriers. The choices available to physiotherapists may be based on cost, departmental knowledge and skill or convenience. However, the best available evidence suggests that physiotherapists should continue to use a biopsychosocial approach when establishing a CSR diagnosis. Physiotherapists should continue to embrace all assessment strategies available and strive to enhance or change practice.
颈椎神经根病[CSR]是一种难以诊断的复杂病症。英国物理治疗师用于诊断CSR的评估方法仍不明确。本研究采用混合方法解释性序列设计,调查英国健康与护理专业委员会(HCPC)物理治疗师在临床实践中使用的评估策略及其决策背后的原因。混合方法研究(MMR)的第一阶段是一项全国性在线调查。63名受访者表示,最常见的评估策略包括肌肉力量(94%)、轻触觉(78%)和反射测试(89%)。MMR研究的第二阶段包括对第一阶段(调查)参与者进行11次定性访谈。确定了四个主题:角色认知、服务限制、风险最小化和症状理解。物理治疗师经常解释说,实践中的决策是基于个人和组织障碍。物理治疗师可选择的方案可能基于成本、部门知识和技能或便利性。然而,现有最佳证据表明,物理治疗师在进行CSR诊断时应继续采用生物心理社会方法。物理治疗师应继续采用所有可用的评估策略,并努力改进或改变实践。