Carlson Per
Stockholm Centre on Health of Societies in Transition, University College of South Stockholm, S-14189 Huddinge, Sweden.
J Epidemiol Community Health. 2005 May;59(5):389-94. doi: 10.1136/jech.2003.017301.
To investigate whether the income distribution in a Russian region has a "contextual" effect on individuals' self rated health, and whether the regional income distributions are related to regional health differences.
The Russia longitudinal monitoring survey (RLMS) is a survey (n = 7696) that is representative of the Russian population. With multilevel regressions both individual as well as contextual effects on self rated health were estimated.
The effect of income inequality is not negative on men's self rated health as long as the level of inequality is not very great. When inequality levels are high, however, there is a tendency for men's health to be negatively affected. Regional health differences among men are in part explained by regional income differences. On the other hand, women do not seem to be affected in the same way, and individual characteristics like age and educational level seem to be more important.
It seems that a rise in income inequality has no negative effect on men's self rated health as long as the level of inequality is not very great. On the other hand, when inequality levels are higher a rise tends to affect men's health negatively. A curvilinear relation between self rated health and income distribution is an interesting hypothesis. It could help to explain the confusing results that arise when you look at countries with a high degree of income inequality (USA) and those with lower income inequality (for example, Japan and New Zealand).
调查俄罗斯某地区的收入分配是否对个人自评健康状况产生“背景”影响,以及地区收入分配是否与地区健康差异相关。
俄罗斯纵向监测调查(RLMS)是一项对俄罗斯人口具有代表性的调查(n = 7696)。通过多层次回归估计了对自评健康状况的个体效应和背景效应。
只要不平等程度不是非常高,收入不平等对男性自评健康状况的影响就不是负面的。然而,当不平等程度较高时,男性健康状况有受到负面影响的趋势。男性的地区健康差异部分可由地区收入差异来解释。另一方面,女性似乎未受到同样的影响,年龄和教育水平等个体特征似乎更为重要。
只要不平等程度不是非常高,收入不平等加剧似乎对男性自评健康状况没有负面影响。另一方面,当不平等程度较高时,不平等加剧往往会对男性健康产生负面影响。自评健康状况与收入分配之间的曲线关系是一个有趣的假设。这有助于解释在观察收入不平等程度高的国家(美国)和收入不平等程度低的国家(例如日本和新西兰)时出现的令人困惑的结果。