Tassinari Davide, Drudi Fabrizio, Carloni Federica, Possenti Cinzia, Santelmo Carlotta, Castellani Cinzia
Modulo di Terapie di Supporto e Palliative, Ospedale Civile Infermi, Rimini.
Recenti Prog Med. 2011 May;102(5):220-7. doi: 10.1701/659.7673.
Neuropathic pain is usually considered an "hard pain" both for the intrinsic difficulties in a correct diagnosis, and for the modest efficacy of the most part of conventional treatments. The most frequently used drugs in clinical practice are tricyclic antidepressants and anticonvulsants, while a minor role is reserved to NSAIDs or to strong opiates. Aim of our work was to systematically analyze all the evidences of literature about the treatment options against neuropathic pain in oncology, focusing our attention upon the efficacy and the safety of the different therapeutic options assessed as Number-Needed-to-Treat (NNT) and Number-Needed-to-Harm (NNH). A critical analysis of literature was finally performed using the GRADE system. On the basis of our review and the NNT and NNH ratio, gabapentin, pregabalin and strong opiates seem to be the most effective and well tolerated options against neuropathic pain in oncology, while carbamazepine, amitryptiline, tramadol and NSAIDs do not seem to be valid options in front line approach against oncologic neuropathic pain, either for a minor efficacy or for an unfavorable safety profile. Further trials comparing the different effective options are needed to better define the correct approach against neuropathic pain in oncology.
神经病理性疼痛通常被视为一种“难治性疼痛”,这既是因为正确诊断存在内在困难,也是因为大多数传统治疗方法的疗效有限。临床实践中最常用的药物是三环类抗抑郁药和抗惊厥药,而非甾体抗炎药或强效阿片类药物的作用较小。我们这项工作的目的是系统分析关于肿瘤学中神经病理性疼痛治疗选择的所有文献证据,重点关注以治疗所需人数(NNT)和伤害所需人数(NNH)评估的不同治疗选择的疗效和安全性。最后使用GRADE系统对文献进行了批判性分析。根据我们的综述以及NNT和NNH比率,加巴喷丁、普瑞巴林和强效阿片类药物似乎是治疗肿瘤学中神经病理性疼痛最有效且耐受性良好的选择,而卡马西平、阿米替林、曲马多和非甾体抗炎药在一线治疗肿瘤性神经病理性疼痛时似乎并非有效选择,要么疗效欠佳,要么安全性不佳。需要进一步比较不同有效选择的试验,以更好地确定治疗肿瘤学中神经病理性疼痛的正确方法。