Shaw Ina, Kinsey Janine E, Richards Roxanne, Shaw Brandon S
Prof. Ina Shaw, PhD. Department of Sport & Movement Studies, University of Johannesburg, Republic of South Africa.
Ms. Janine E. Kinsey, B.Hons. Department of Sport & Movement Studies, University of Johannesburg, Republic of South Africa.
Pak J Med Sci. 2016 Sep-Oct;32(5):1152-1157. doi: 10.12669/pjms.325.9960.
BACKGROUND & OBJECTIVE: Since dyspnea limits exercise adherence and intensity in cystic fibrosis (CF) patients, engaging in resistance training (RT), which causes less dyspnea than other exercise modalities, while using nebulizers could not only overcome this barrier, but also enhance long-term adaptations to treatment. The objective of this study was to examine the effects of RT during nebulization on spirometry, anthropometry, chest wall excursion, respiratory muscle strength and health-related quality of life (HRQOL).
Fourteen male and female CF patients were assigned to a four-week, 20-minute, 5-day per week proof-of-concept RT group (RTG) (n=7) or non-exercising control group (CON) (n=7), with 3 CON patients later dropping out of the study. Patients performed whole body exercises for 3 sets of 10 reps using resistance bands, since such bands have previously demonstrated a greater effect on functional exercise capacity than conventional RT in lung patients.
The RTG displayed significant (p≤0.05) increases in FEV, FEV/FVC, latissimusdorsi strength, pectoralis major clavicular portion strength, pectoralis major sternocostal portion strength and emotional and digestion HRQOL domains, while decreasing pectoralis minor strength on the left and social, body image and respiration HRQOL domains.
This small scale proof-of-concept investigation demonstrates the multiple and simultaneous benefits of RT during nebulization in CF patients. The improvements in pulmonary measures are particularly promising especially since this study only made use of a four-week experimental period. This study provides an important alternative, time-saving treatment for the CF patient that does not add to the treatment burden of CF patients.
由于呼吸困难会限制囊性纤维化(CF)患者的运动依从性和运动强度,进行阻力训练(RT),相较于其他运动方式,其引发的呼吸困难较少,同时使用雾化器,不仅可以克服这一障碍,还能增强长期治疗适应性。本研究的目的是探讨雾化期间进行阻力训练对肺功能测定、人体测量、胸壁运动、呼吸肌力量以及健康相关生活质量(HRQOL)的影响。
14名男性和女性CF患者被分配到一个为期四周、每周5天、每次20分钟的概念验证性阻力训练组(RTG)(n = 7)或非运动对照组(CON)(n = 7),CON组有3名患者后来退出了研究。患者使用弹力带进行全身锻炼,每组10次,共3组,因为此前已证明这种弹力带对肺部患者的功能性运动能力的影响大于传统阻力训练。
RTG组的第1秒用力呼气容积(FEV)、FEV/用力肺活量(FVC)、背阔肌力量、胸大肌锁骨部力量、胸大肌胸骨部力量以及情绪和消化方面的HRQOL领域均有显著(p≤0.05)提高,而左侧胸小肌力量以及社交、身体形象和呼吸方面的HRQOL领域则有所下降。
这项小规模的概念验证性研究证明了CF患者在雾化期间进行阻力训练具有多重且同时存在的益处。肺部指标的改善尤其令人期待,特别是因为本研究仅采用了四周的实验期。本研究为CF患者提供了一种重要的、节省时间的替代治疗方法,且不会增加CF患者的治疗负担。