Nigerian Field Epidemiology and Laboratory Training Programme (NFELTP), Abuja, Federal Capital Territory, Nigeria.
Department of Community Medicine, Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria, Kaduna State, Nigeria.
PLoS One. 2019 Dec 31;14(12):e0207499. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0207499. eCollection 2019.
Physicians and nurses play vital roles in addressing palliative care (PC) needs of people living with HIV/AIDS (PLWHA). The healthcare workers' (HCWs) experiences determine the success of palliative care delivery. There is paucity of data on PC for PLWHA. For this reason, we assessed the knowledge, attitude and practice of PC for PLWHA and associated factors among health care professionals.
We conducted a cross-sectional descriptive study among HCWs in public health facilities in the Federal Capital Territory, Nigeria between February and May, 2017. Multistage sampling technique with proportionate-to-size allocation was used to determine facility sample size and HCWs per professional discipline. Data were collected with questionnaires adapted from Palliative Care Quiz for Nursing, Frommelt Attitude toward Care of the Dying and practical questions adapted from PC standard guidelines. Participants' knowledge, attitude and practice were assessed by awarding one (1) point for each correct answer; incorrect or "not sure" answers took a zero (0) score. Correct responses were summed up to get a total score for each participant. Descriptive statistics was done to describe frequencies and proportions displayed on tables. Linear regression was done to determine factors associated with HCW's knowledge, attitude and practice of PC for PLWHA.
With a 100% response rate, the mean age of the 348 participants was 37.5 years (SD: ±8.9), 201 (57.8%) were female, 222 (63.8) were nurses and 230 (66.0%) had a work experience of 10 years or less. Majority of the participants, 310 (89.1%) agreed that palliative care focuses on the relief and prevention of suffering and 319 (91.7%) believe that PLWHA required palliative care. Misconceptions about palliative care include "palliative care is disease-oriented and not person oriented", 252 (72.6%) believed; "palliative care is concerned with prolongation of life", 279 (80.6%); and "use of placebos is appropriate in the treatment of some types of pain", 252 (72.6%). Among the participants, 52% disagreed that "palliative care should be given only for dying PLWHA" while only 18 (5.2%) were right on "family should be involved in the physical care of the dying PLWHA". Majority of the participants, 292 (84.1%) initiated palliative care discussion during patients' diagnosis while 290 (83.6%) informed terminally ill patients about their diagnosis. Regarding psychological issues, 22 (6.3%) participants hid the truth from the patients while 196 (56.3%) provided emotional support to the patients. Morphine 240 (69.0%) and Pentazocine 194 (55.7%) were the most commonly used drugs for treatment of severe pain by participants across all centres.
In-service training and undergraduate training on palliative care were associated with knowledge and practice of palliative care for people living with HIV/AIDS. We recommended continuous quality in-service training and education on palliative care for HCWs. While we ensure voluntariness of participation and other ethical principles, the high response rate could be as a result of more motivated health worker than the norm. The results are unlikely to be representative of doctors and nurses in primary health care centres.
医生和护士在满足艾滋病毒/艾滋病(HIV/AIDS)患者的姑息治疗(PC)需求方面发挥着至关重要的作用。医护人员的经验决定了姑息治疗服务的成功与否。目前,针对 HIV/AIDS 患者的姑息治疗数据很少。因此,我们评估了卫生保健专业人员对 HIV/AIDS 患者姑息治疗的知识、态度和实践及其相关因素。
我们于 2017 年 2 月至 5 月在尼日利亚联邦首都特区的公共卫生机构中进行了一项横断面描述性研究。采用多阶段抽样技术和按比例大小分配的方法,确定了设施样本量和每个专业学科的卫生保健工作者人数。我们使用从姑息治疗护理护理问卷、Frommelt 临终关怀态度和从姑息治疗标准指南改编的实际问题改编的问卷收集数据。参与者的知识、态度和实践通过给予每个正确答案 1 分来评估;错误或“不确定”的答案得 0 分。每个参与者的正确答案被加总以获得总分。描述性统计用于在表格中显示频率和比例。线性回归用于确定与 HCW 对 HIV/AIDS 患者姑息治疗的知识、态度和实践相关的因素。
在 100%的回应率下,348 名参与者的平均年龄为 37.5 岁(SD:±8.9),201 名(57.8%)为女性,222 名(63.8%)为护士,230 名(66.0%)工作经验在 10 年或以下。大多数参与者(89.1%)同意姑息治疗的重点是缓解和预防痛苦,319 名(91.7%)认为 HIV/AIDS 患者需要姑息治疗。对姑息治疗的误解包括“姑息治疗以疾病为导向,不以人为导向”,252 名(72.6%)认为;“姑息治疗关注的是延长生命”,279 名(80.6%);“在某些类型的疼痛治疗中使用安慰剂是合适的”,252 名(72.6%)。在参与者中,52%的人不同意“姑息治疗只应给予濒临死亡的 HIV/AIDS 患者”,而只有 18 人(5.2%)正确回答“家属应参与临终 HIV/AIDS 患者的身体护理”。大多数参与者(84.1%)在患者诊断期间开始姑息治疗讨论,而 290 名(83.6%)告知绝症患者他们的诊断。关于心理问题,22 名(6.3%)参与者向患者隐瞒了真相,而 196 名(56.3%)向患者提供了情感支持。在所有中心,参与者最常使用的药物是吗啡 240 名(69.0%)和戊四唑 194 名(55.7%)来治疗严重疼痛。
姑息治疗在职培训和本科培训与艾滋病毒/艾滋病患者姑息治疗的知识和实践相关。我们建议对姑息治疗进行持续的质量在职培训和教育。虽然我们确保参与的自愿性和其他伦理原则,但高回应率可能是由于比正常情况更有动力的卫生工作者。结果不太可能代表初级保健中心的医生和护士。