Ministry of Health, Muscat, Oman.
J Prim Care Community Health. 2020 Jan-Dec;11:2150132720976480. doi: 10.1177/2150132720976480.
To enforce physical distancing measures during COVID-19, Telephone Consultation (TC), a form of telemedicine, was initiated as an alternative technology to face to face consultation in primary health care (PHC) in Muscat, Oman. This study aims to explore the perceptions of physicians about the use of TC with respect to process of implementation; challenges and limitations; lessons learned and the way forward.
This was a qualitative study using interpretive phenomenological analysis. Physicians who were actively conducting TC in PHC were purposively selected and individually interviewed until no new responses were obtained. All interviews were audio-recorded, transcribed verbatim, and analysed using thematic analysis.
Twenty-two participants were interviewed. Participants were predominantly females (98%) and qualified family physicians (77.3%). Overall, all participants accepted this initiative as a possible method to continue health services during COVID-19. Perceptions about the process of implementing TC in PHC were themed to; inconsistent implementation of the guideline, variability in roles and responsibilities, and Semi-supportive infrastructure. Five themes were identified as challenges and limitations: limited staff training on TC, suboptimal patient-physician interaction, insufficient technical support, ensuring privacy, and confidentiality of the communication, and different ways to document the TC. Physicians expressed that TC worked better in following COVID-19 cases, chronic conditions, and, in general, simple cases. They also expressed a reduction in the crowdedness in PHC facilities and the risk of acquiring COVID-19 and other types of infections. Tailoring the existing structural clinical setting, capacity building activities on the use of TC, and improving the quality of the TC are viewed as essential steps for the future sustainability of TC in PHC.
Given the exceptional situation of COVID-19, the current evidence suggests that the use of TC in PHC, especially in chronic cases, is promising. However, measures including training of staff, improving the structural setting, and selecting suitable cases for TC are the main elements for high quality and sustainable TC services in PHC from physician's perspective.
为了在 COVID-19 期间实施身体距离措施,电话咨询(TC)作为远程医疗的一种形式,在阿曼马斯喀特的初级保健(PHC)中被作为面对面咨询的替代技术而启动。本研究旨在探讨医生对使用 TC 的看法,包括实施过程;挑战和限制;经验教训和前进方向。
这是一项定性研究,采用解释性现象学分析。选择正在 PHC 中积极进行 TC 的医生进行有针对性的访谈,直到获得新的回应。所有访谈均进行录音、逐字记录,并使用主题分析进行分析。
共访谈了 22 名参与者。参与者主要为女性(98%)和合格的家庭医生(77.3%)。总体而言,所有参与者都接受了这一倡议,认为这是在 COVID-19 期间继续提供卫生服务的一种可能方法。在 PHC 中实施 TC 的实施过程的看法被主题化为:指南实施不一致、角色和责任的可变性、半支持性基础设施。确定了五个主题作为挑战和限制:对 TC 的员工培训有限、医患互动不理想、技术支持不足、确保沟通的隐私和保密性,以及 TC 的不同记录方式。医生们表示,TC 对 COVID-19 病例、慢性病以及一般简单病例的效果更好。他们还表示,PHC 设施的拥挤程度有所减少,感染 COVID-19 和其他类型感染的风险也有所降低。从医生的角度来看,调整现有结构性临床环境、开展 TC 使用能力建设活动以及提高 TC 质量被视为 TC 在 PHC 可持续发展的必要步骤。
鉴于 COVID-19 的特殊情况,目前的证据表明,在 PHC 中使用 TC,特别是在慢性病病例中,是有前途的。然而,从医生的角度来看,包括培训员工、改善结构性环境和选择适合 TC 的病例在内的措施是高质量和可持续 TC 服务的主要要素。