Department of Health, Ethics and Society, School of Public Health and Primary Care (CAPHRI), Maastricht University, Maastricht, The Netherlands.
Department of Faculty Paediatrics, Siberian State Medical University, Tomsk, Russian Federation.
Sociol Health Illn. 2021 Feb;43(2):353-368. doi: 10.1111/1467-9566.13224. Epub 2021 Feb 26.
Antimicrobial resistance control programmes often aim to "fix" the behaviour of antibiotic users and prescribers. Such behavioural interventions have been widely criticised in social science literature for being inefficient and too narrow in scope. Drawing on these criticisms, this article analyses how political programmes for fixing antibiotic behaviours were adapted into the practices of health-care professionals and patients in Russia. In 2018, we conducted interviews with medical doctors, pharmacists and patients in a Russian city; focusing on their practices around the policy requirement introduced in 2017 which obligated medical prescriptions of antibiotics. We conceptualised the obligatory medical prescription as a political technique which sought to change practices of self-treatment and over-the-counter sales of medications by establishing doctors as an obligatory passage point to access antibiotics. Our analysis shows that the requirement for medical prescriptions does not fulfil the infrastructural gaps that influence antibiotic practices. By navigating the antibiotic prescriptions, doctors, pharmacists and patients informally compensate for the gaps in the existing infrastructure creating informal networks of antibiotic care parallel to the requirement of obligatory prescriptions. Following these informal practices, we could map the inconsistencies in the current policy approaches to tackle AMR as a behavioural rather than infrastructural problem.
抗菌药物耐药性控制项目通常旨在“纠正”抗生素使用者和处方者的行为。在社会科学文献中,这种行为干预因其效率低下且范围过于狭窄而受到广泛批评。本文借鉴了这些批评意见,分析了将纠正抗生素行为的政治方案如何适应俄罗斯医疗保健专业人员和患者的实践。2018 年,我们在俄罗斯的一个城市对医生、药剂师和患者进行了访谈;重点关注他们在 2017 年引入的政策要求下的实践,该政策要求医疗开具抗生素处方。我们将强制性医疗处方概念化为一种政治手段,旨在通过将医生确立为获得抗生素的必经途径,改变自我治疗和非处方药物销售的做法。我们的分析表明,强制性医疗处方的要求并不能填补影响抗生素实践的基础设施差距。通过管理抗生素处方,医生、药剂师和患者非正式地弥补了现有基础设施中的差距,在强制性处方要求的基础上建立了抗生素护理的非正式网络。根据这些非正式实践,我们可以发现当前解决 AMR 的政策方法将其视为行为问题而不是基础设施问题的不一致性。