The Newcastle Upon Tyne hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, Newcastle Upon Tyne, UK.
Gloucestershire Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, Gloucester, UK.
Eye (Lond). 2022 Jan;36(1):72-77. doi: 10.1038/s41433-021-01625-8. Epub 2021 Jul 9.
Randomised controlled trials provide evidence that a treatment works. Real world evidence is required to assess if proven treatments are effective in practice.
Retrospective data collection on patients given aflibercept for diabetic macular oedema over 3 years from 21 UK hospitals: visual acuity (VA); Index of multiple deprivation score (IMD); injection numbers; protocols used, compared as a cohort and between sites.
Complete data: 1742 patients (from 2196 eligible) at 1 year, 860 (from 1270) at 2, 305 (from 506) at 3 years. The median VA improved from 65 to 71, 70, 70 (ETDRS letters) at 1, 2 and 3 years with 6, 9 and 12 injections, respectively. Loss to follow-up: 10% 1 year, 28.8% at 3. Centres varied: baseline: mean age 61-71 years (p < 0.0001); mean IMD score 15-37 (p < 0.0001); mean VA 49-68 (p < 0.0001). Only four centres provided a loading course of five injections at monthly intervals and one 6. This did not alter VA outcome at 1 year. Higher IMD was associated with younger age (p = 0.0023) and worse VA at baseline (p < 0.0001) not total number of injections or change in VA. Lower starting VA, higher IMD and older age were associated with lower adherence (p = 0.0010).
The data showed significant variation between treatment centres for starting age, VA and IMD which influenced adherence and chances of good VA. Once treatment was started IMD did not alter likelihood of improvement. Loading dose intensity did not alter outcome at one year.
随机对照试验提供了治疗有效的证据。需要真实世界的证据来评估已证明的治疗方法在实践中的有效性。
从 21 家英国医院收集了 3 年来接受阿柏西普治疗糖尿病性黄斑水肿的患者的回顾性数据:视力(VA);多因素剥夺指数评分(IMD);注射次数;比较了所使用的方案,并按队列和站点进行了比较。
完整数据:1 年时有 1742 名患者(来自 2196 名合格患者),2 年时有 860 名(来自 1270 名),3 年时有 305 名(来自 506 名)。VA 中位数从 65 提高到 71、70、70(ETDRS 字母),分别接受 6、9 和 12 次注射。失访率:1 年时为 10%,3 年时为 28.8%。中心之间存在差异:基线:平均年龄 61-71 岁(p<0.0001);平均 IMD 评分 15-37(p<0.0001);平均 VA 49-68(p<0.0001)。只有 4 个中心提供了每月间隔 5 次注射的负荷疗程和 1 次 6 次注射的负荷疗程。这并没有改变 1 年时的 VA 结果。较高的 IMD 与较年轻的年龄(p=0.0023)和较差的基线 VA(p<0.0001)相关,而与总注射次数或 VA 变化无关。较低的起始 VA、较高的 IMD 和较老的年龄与较低的依从性相关(p=0.0010)。
数据显示治疗中心之间在起始年龄、VA 和 IMD 方面存在显著差异,这些差异影响了依从性和良好 VA 的机会。一旦开始治疗,IMD 就不会改变改善的可能性。负荷剂量强度并没有改变一年时的结果。