Smyth Emer, Murray Aisling
Economic and Social Research Institute, D02 K138 Dublin, Ireland.
Children (Basel). 2022 Jul 12;9(7):1037. doi: 10.3390/children9071037.
The sudden health and economic crisis brought about by the COVID-19 pandemic affords an opportunity to examine the impact of economic disruption to children and families. Any negative effects on the well-being of children are important to consider in relation to both short- and long-term outcomes. Using pre-pandemic and mid-pandemic waves of the longitudinal Growing Up in Ireland study, we examined whether the impact of economic disruption was equivalent for families who were (or were not) financially vulnerable pre-pandemic. We then investigated whether economic disruption was associated with a negative effect on the emotional well-being of 12-year-olds, and if there was evidence for such a negative effect being mediated through a lack of material resources or strain on family dynamics. Our results indicated that middle-income rather than lowest-income families experienced the most economic disruption, likely reflecting the sector-specific nature of business closures in the pandemic. Families who were financially vulnerable pre-pandemic were less likely to have had suitable resources for homeschooling. Both falls in income and strain in family relationships, such as arguing more with their parents, were associated with poorer scores on a measure of the child's emotional well-being. The emergency income support payment introduced at the start of the pandemic appeared to have a protective effect on the association between family income loss and child well-being, which has wider implications for policy on child poverty.
由新冠疫情引发的突发健康和经济危机为审视经济混乱对儿童及家庭的影响提供了契机。就短期和长期结果而言,任何对儿童福祉的负面影响都值得考虑。利用爱尔兰纵向研究“成长在爱尔兰”中疫情前和疫情中期的数据,我们研究了经济混乱对疫情前经济状况脆弱(或不脆弱)家庭的影响是否相同。然后,我们调查了经济混乱是否与12岁儿童的情绪健康受到负面影响有关,以及是否有证据表明这种负面影响是通过物质资源匮乏或家庭关系紧张介导的。我们的结果表明,中等收入家庭而非低收入家庭经历了最严重的经济混乱,这可能反映了疫情期间企业关闭的行业特定性质。疫情前经济状况脆弱的家庭不太可能拥有适合在家上学的资源。收入下降和家庭关系紧张,比如与父母争吵增多,都与儿童情绪健康指标得分较低有关。疫情初期推出的紧急收入支持款项似乎对家庭收入损失与儿童福祉之间的关联起到了保护作用,这对儿童贫困政策具有更广泛的意义。