Elder Mark, Ellis Gemma
Institute for Global Environmental Strategies, 2108-11 Kamiyamaguchi, Hayama, Kanagawa 240-0115 Japan.
Environ Dev Sustain. 2022 Jul 23:1-19. doi: 10.1007/s10668-022-02514-0.
This study's objective is to examine how ASEAN countries reported their environment-related policies for the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in their Voluntary National Reviews (VNRs), and a dataset of their environmental policies was developed. This is a necessary first step in analyzing the reasons for insufficient progress on the environmental dimension of the SDGs, since policies are key means of implementation. Previous studies of SDG progress and VNRs examined many aspects such as achievement levels, indicators, data, governance, and VNR preparation procedures, but surprisingly, there has been little discussion of countries' actual policy efforts. Progress on the SDGs' environmental dimensions is widely considered insufficient, including in Asia. This study showed that insufficient progress on the environmental dimension of the SDGs is not due to a lack of environmental policies or a lower prioritization of policies for environmental SDG targets. ASEAN countries included almost 600 concrete environment-related policies in their VNRs, widely distributed among most SDGs, accounting for about 40 percent of their total reported SDG-related policies. The number of environmental policies was not closely related to GDP, GDP per capita, or VNR date. Many policies appeared substantial, including national action plans, strategies, laws, and regulations, not just small projects or programs. However, some major existing environmental policies, for example on air pollution, were usually not included in the VNRs. Further research is needed to explore other possible factors such as insufficient policy implementation or effectiveness, which this study could not examine. This study's environmental policy dataset provides the necessary baseline for future research on policy implementation and effectiveness, especially to help future studies identify ASEAN countries' environmental policies in specific areas such as climate, energy, or water. This will also facilitate comparative analysis.
The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s10668-022-02514-0.
本研究的目的是考察东盟国家如何在其国家自愿报告(VNR)中汇报其与可持续发展目标(SDG)相关的环境政策,并编制了一份其环境政策数据集。这是分析可持续发展目标环境层面进展不足原因的必要第一步,因为政策是关键的实施手段。以往关于可持续发展目标进展和国家自愿报告的研究考察了许多方面,如成就水平、指标、数据、治理和国家自愿报告编制程序,但令人惊讶的是,对于各国实际的政策努力讨论甚少。人们普遍认为可持续发展目标环境层面的进展不足,亚洲地区亦是如此。本研究表明,可持续发展目标环境层面进展不足并非由于缺乏环境政策或对环境可持续发展目标的政策优先度较低。东盟国家在其国家自愿报告中纳入了近600项具体的环境相关政策,广泛分布于大多数可持续发展目标中,约占其报告的与可持续发展目标相关政策总数的40%。环境政策的数量与国内生产总值、人均国内生产总值或国家自愿报告日期没有密切关系。许多政策看起来很充实,包括国家行动计划、战略、法律和法规,而不仅仅是小型项目或计划。然而,一些现有的主要环境政策,例如关于空气污染的政策,通常未被纳入国家自愿报告。需要进一步研究以探索其他可能的因素,如政策实施不足或有效性不足,本研究无法对此进行考察。本研究的环境政策数据集为未来关于政策实施和有效性的研究提供了必要的基线,特别是有助于未来研究识别东盟国家在气候、能源或水等特定领域的环境政策。这也将便于进行比较分析。
在线版本包含可在10.1007/s10668-022-02514-0获取的补充材料。