Johnson Mark I
Centre for Pain Research, School of Health, Leeds Beckett University, City Campus, Leeds LS1 3HE, UK.
Behav Sci (Basel). 2025 May 20;15(5):703. doi: 10.3390/bs15050703.
Despite the proliferation of biomedical and psychological treatments, the global burden of chronic intractable (long-term) pain remains high-a treatment-prevalence paradox. The biopsychosocial model, introduced in the 1970s, is central to strategies for managing pain, but has been criticised for being decontextualised and fragmented, compromising the effectiveness of healthcare pain support services and patient care. The aim of this study was to apply a simplified version of Ken Wilber's All Quadrant All Levels (AQAL) framework to pain in a healthcare context to advance a biopsychosocial understanding. Utilising domain knowledge, the author mapped features of pain and coping to intrasubjective, intraobjective, intersubjective, and interobjective quadrants (perspectives), as well as levels of psychological development. Narratives were crafted to synthesize the findings of mapping with literature from diverse disciplines within the contexts of salutogenesis and a social model of health. The findings showed that AQAL-mapping enhanced contextual biopsychosocial coherence and exposed the conceptual error of reifying pain. Its utility lay in highlighting upstream influences of the painogenic environment, supporting the reconfiguration of pain within a social model of health, as exemplified by the UK's Rethinking Pain Service. In conclusion, a simple version of the AQAL framework served as a heuristic device to develop an integral vision of pain, opening opportunities for health promotion solutions within a salutogenic context.
尽管生物医学和心理治疗方法不断涌现,但慢性顽固性(长期)疼痛的全球负担仍然很高——这是一种治疗流行率的悖论。20世纪70年代引入的生物心理社会模型是疼痛管理策略的核心,但因脱离背景和碎片化而受到批评,损害了医疗保健疼痛支持服务和患者护理的有效性。本研究的目的是在医疗保健背景下将肯·威尔伯的全象限全层次(AQAL)框架的简化版本应用于疼痛,以推进对生物心理社会的理解。作者利用领域知识,将疼痛和应对的特征映射到主观内、客观内、主观间和客观间象限(视角)以及心理发展水平。通过叙事将映射结果与健康促进和社会健康模型背景下不同学科的文献进行综合。研究结果表明,AQAL映射增强了背景生物心理社会的连贯性,并揭示了将疼痛具体化的概念错误。其效用在于突出致痛环境的上游影响,支持在社会健康模型中对疼痛进行重新构建,英国的“重新思考疼痛服务”就是例证。总之,AQAL框架的一个简单版本作为一种启发式工具,用于形成对疼痛的整体认识,为健康促进背景下的解决方案创造了机会。