Vriend Paul, Bosker Thijs, Mellink Yvette, Collas Frank, Moscoso Cruz Felipe, Kamp Nadieh, Drok Sylvia, Vijver Martina G, van Emmerik Tim H M
Institute of Environmental Sciences, Leiden University, 2300 RA Leiden, The Netherlands.
Rijkswaterstaat, Ministry of Infrastructure and Water Management, 2515 XP The Hague, The Netherlands.
ACS ES T Water. 2025 Jun 6;5(7):3920-3928. doi: 10.1021/acsestwater.5c00223. eCollection 2025 Jul 11.
Accurate and reliable monitoring data are crucial for the design of effective plastic pollution reduction and mitigation strategies. One common approach to monitor macroplastic (>0.5 cm) in rivers is the visual observation method, where floating plastics are counted from bridges to estimate plastic flux. However, this method lacks robust uncertainty analyses, resulting in unknown error margins and potentially suboptimal monitoring strategies. The goal of this study was to quantify these uncertainties. Three key design elements that contribute to uncertainty include (1) cross-sectional coverage, (2) observation time, and (3) observation frequency. Through a case study on the Dutch Rhine-Meuse delta, we show how these uncertainties can be quantified and that they can be used to make informed monitoring design decisions. We further demonstrate that the detection rate of true flux (recovery rate) is a key parameter to consider during uncertainty analyses. By integrating an uncertainty optimization step into the design process, the efficiency and effectiveness of monitoring protocols can be improved. These insights enhance data quality and reliability, ultimately supporting efforts to mitigate the environmental impacts of macroplastic pollution.
准确可靠的监测数据对于设计有效的塑料污染减少和缓解策略至关重要。监测河流中宏观塑料(>0.5厘米)的一种常见方法是视觉观察法,即从桥上对漂浮的塑料进行计数以估算塑料通量。然而,这种方法缺乏稳健的不确定性分析,导致误差范围未知以及监测策略可能不够优化。本研究的目的是量化这些不确定性。导致不确定性的三个关键设计要素包括:(1)横断面覆盖范围,(2)观察时间,以及(3)观察频率。通过对荷兰莱茵 - 默兹三角洲的案例研究,我们展示了如何量化这些不确定性,以及它们如何用于做出明智的监测设计决策。我们进一步证明,真实通量的检测率(回收率)是不确定性分析过程中需要考虑的关键参数。通过将不确定性优化步骤纳入设计过程,可以提高监测方案的效率和有效性。这些见解提高了数据质量和可靠性,最终支持减轻宏观塑料污染对环境影响的努力。