Mortellaro Claudia, Giannottu Elena, Pedrelli Camilla, Lorenzi Valentina, Pietropaoli Marco, Manara Veronica, Girola Martina, De Carolis Alessandra, Bagni Marina, Formato Giovanni
Istituto Zooprofilattico Sperimentale del Lazio e Della Toscana "M. Aleandri", International Cooperation and Research for Sustainable Development in Beekeeping Laboratory, FAO Reference Centre, "Animal Health and Food Security Discipline Apiculture, Health and Biosecurity", WOAH Collaborating Centre, "Good Beekeeping Management Practices and Biosecurity Measures in the Apiculture Sector", Via Appia Nuova 1411, 00178 Rome, Italy.
Indipendent Veterinary Practitioner, 00147 Rome, Italy.
Animals (Basel). 2025 Jul 30;15(15):2236. doi: 10.3390/ani15152236.
Honey bees are vital to ecosystem conservation, agricultural production, and biodiversity, yet their welfare has often been overlooked. This study introduces the integration of Honey Bee Welfare Practices (HBWPs) into the One Welfare framework, addressing the interconnectedness of honey bee welfare, environmental welfare, and human wellbeing. We analysed and re-evaluated the 243 HBWPs already identified and categorised within the context of the Five Domains model in 2024 by Giovanni Formato et al., and we explored their broader impacts. By incorporating the One Welfare approach, we assessed each practice's effect on bee welfare both as individuals and as a superorganism, human wellbeing, and environmental welfare, as well as their economic and time-related implications for beekeepers. The aim of this study was to obtain a list of One Welfare Practices in Beekeeping, considering all stakeholders as equally important. The analysis highlights the multidimensional nature of beekeeping, with 280 practices positively affecting honey bee welfare, while also considering their potential impact on human wellbeing, environmental health, and production. Challenges such as balancing beekeeper time constraints and welfare goals are discussed, with recommendations for practical compromises. This approach can offer a holistic and sustainable model for apiculture, ensuring that welfare is maintained across all stakeholders, and provides a flexible framework applicable to various beekeeping systems worldwide.
蜜蜂对生态系统保护、农业生产和生物多样性至关重要,但其福利却常常被忽视。本研究介绍了将蜜蜂福利实践(HBWPs)纳入“同一福利”框架,以解决蜜蜂福利、环境福利和人类福祉之间的相互联系。我们分析并重新评估了乔瓦尼·福尔马托等人在2024年根据五域模型已识别和分类的243种HBWPs,并探讨了它们更广泛的影响。通过纳入“同一福利”方法,我们评估了每种实践对蜜蜂个体和超级有机体福利、人类福祉、环境福利的影响,以及它们对养蜂人的经济和时间影响。本研究的目的是获得一份养蜂业“同一福利”实践清单,将所有利益相关者视为同等重要。分析突出了养蜂业的多维度性质,有280种实践对蜜蜂福利有积极影响,同时也考虑了它们对人类福祉、环境健康和生产的潜在影响。讨论了平衡养蜂人时间限制和福利目标等挑战,并提出了实际折中的建议。这种方法可以为养蜂业提供一个全面和可持续的模式,确保所有利益相关者的福利都能得到维护,并提供一个适用于全球各种养蜂系统的灵活框架。