Salazar Mark R, Saini Lalima, Nguyen Tran B, Pinkerton Kent E, Madl Amy K, Cole Austin M, Poulin Brett A
Department of Environmental Toxicology, University of California Davis, Davis, California 95616, United States.
Center for Health and the Environment, University of California Davis, Davis, California 95616, United States.
ACS Cent Sci. 2025 Jun 25;11(8):1345-1354. doi: 10.1021/acscentsci.5c00641. eCollection 2025 Aug 27.
The rapidly evolving market of disposable e-cigarettes poses unknown health risks to adolescents and young adults. We report excessive emissions of toxic metallic elements in aerosols from flavored and "clear" versions of three popular products (Esco Bar, Flum Pebble, and ELF Bar), orders of magnitude higher in concentration than traditional cigarettes and other e-cigarettes. Heating coil elements (chromium (Cr), nickel (Ni)) likely leached into e-liquids and aerosols from coil degradation during use, increasing up to 1000-fold in concentration over the device life. In Esco Bar devices, high concentrations of lead (Pb, ≤175 ppm), Ni (≤38 ppm), copper (Cu, ≤546 ppm), and zinc (Zn, ≤462 ppm) were observed in both e-liquids and aerosols. We identified the illicit use of leaded bronze in nonheating device components in contact with e-liquid as the source of Pb. Elevated antimony (Sb) in Flum Pebble and Esco Bar samples had unknown origins. Analyses showed Cr was present as nontoxic Cr-(III), while Sb was a mixture of nontoxic Sb-(V) and carcinogenic Sb-(III). Risk assessments revealed cancer risks from Ni and Sb-(III) and noncancer toxicity risks from Pb and Ni exceeded safety thresholds. These findings highlight critical gaps in e-cigarette regulation, characterization, and enforcement, with implications for public health.
一次性电子烟市场的迅速发展给青少年和年轻人带来了未知的健康风险。我们报告了三种流行产品(Esco Bar、Flum Pebble和ELF Bar)的调味型和“原味”版本的气溶胶中有毒金属元素的过量排放,其浓度比传统香烟和其他电子烟高出几个数量级。加热线圈元件(铬(Cr)、镍(Ni))在使用过程中可能因线圈降解而渗入电子烟液和气溶胶中,在设备使用寿命期间浓度增加高达1000倍。在Esco Bar设备中,在电子烟液和气溶胶中均观察到高浓度的铅(Pb,≤175 ppm)、镍(Ni,≤38 ppm)、铜(Cu,≤546 ppm)和锌(Zn,≤462 ppm)。我们确定与电子烟液接触的非加热设备部件中非法使用含铅青铜是铅的来源。Flum Pebble和Esco Bar样品中锑(Sb)含量升高,来源不明。分析表明,铬以无毒的Cr-(III)形式存在,而锑是无毒的Sb-(V)和致癌的Sb-(III)的混合物。风险评估显示,镍和Sb-(III)带来的癌症风险以及铅和镍带来的非癌症毒性风险超过了安全阈值。这些发现凸显了电子烟监管、特性描述和执法方面的关键差距,对公众健康具有重要意义。