Vinken A G, Bathalon G P, Sawaya A L, Dallal G E, Tucker K L, Roberts S B
Jean Mayer US Department of Agriculture Human Nutrition Research Center on Aging at Tufts University, Boston, MA 02111, USA.
Am J Clin Nutr. 1999 May;69(5):920-6. doi: 10.1093/ajcn/69.5.920.
Recent studies have questioned the accuracy of using the current recommended dietary allowances (RDAs) to predict usual energy requirements in adults.
We developed equations to predict adult energy requirements from simple anthropometric and laboratory measures by using the doubly labeled water method to determine each subject's total energy expenditure (TEE), which is equal to usual energy requirements in weight-stable individuals.
This was a cross-sectional study conducted with 93 healthy, free-living adults [44 men and 49 women; body mass index range (in kg/m2): 18.4-31.8] aged 18-81 y. Body fat and fat-free mass were measured by underwater weighing, physical activity was estimated by using activity monitors, and resting energy expenditure was determined by indirect calorimetry. Information on anthropometric variables and reported strenuous activity was also collected.
Three regression equations were developed and verified for accuracy by using bootstrap analysis and doubly labeled water data published by other research groups. The first equation used information on only age, weight, height, and sex and had an SEE for prediction of TEE of 1.80 MJ/d. The second and third equations used different combinations of basic and laboratory data and had SEEs of 1.55 and 1.65 MJ/d, respectively. With use of the same analytic approaches, the RDAs for energy were shown to significantly underestimate usual energy needs by approximately 10%; the extent of underestimation was significantly greater for subjects with high TEEs than for subjects with low TEEs.
Regression equations based on doubly labeled water measurements of TEE appear to be more accurate than the current RDAs for predicting energy requirements in healthy, nonobese adults living in affluent countries.
近期研究对使用当前推荐膳食摄入量(RDA)来预测成年人的日常能量需求的准确性提出了质疑。
我们通过使用双标水法来确定每个受试者的总能量消耗(TEE),该能量消耗等于体重稳定个体的日常能量需求,从而开发出从简单人体测量和实验室指标预测成年人能量需求的方程。
这是一项针对93名18 - 81岁健康、自由生活的成年人[44名男性和49名女性;体重指数范围(kg/m²):18.4 - 31.8]进行的横断面研究。通过水下称重测量体脂和去脂体重,使用活动监测器估算身体活动,通过间接测热法测定静息能量消耗。还收集了人体测量变量和报告的剧烈活动信息。
开发了三个回归方程,并通过自抽样分析和其他研究小组发表的双标水数据验证其准确性。第一个方程仅使用年龄、体重、身高和性别的信息,预测TEE的估计标准误为1.80 MJ/d。第二个和第三个方程使用基础数据和实验室数据的不同组合,估计标准误分别为1.55和1.65 MJ/d。使用相同的分析方法,能量的RDA被证明显著低估日常能量需求约10%;高TEE受试者的低估程度显著高于低TEE受试者。
基于双标水测量TEE的回归方程在预测生活在富裕国家的健康、非肥胖成年人的能量需求方面似乎比当前的RDA更准确。