Gaskell Helen, Derry Sheena, Stannard Cathy, Moore R Andrew
Pain Research and Nuffield Department of Clinical Neurosciences (Nuffield Division of Anaesthetics), University of Oxford, Oxford, Oxfordshire, UK.
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2016 Jul 28;7(7):CD010692. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD010692.pub3.
This is an update of an earlier review that considered both neuropathic pain and fibromyalgia (Issue 6, 2014), which has now been split into separate reviews for the two conditions. This review considers neuropathic pain only.Opioid drugs, including oxycodone, are commonly used to treat neuropathic pain, and are considered effective by some professionals. Most reviews have examined all opioids together. This review sought evidence specifically for oxycodone, at any dose, and by any route of administration. Separate reviews consider other opioids.
To assess the analgesic efficacy and adverse events of oxycodone for chronic neuropathic pain in adults.
We searched the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL), MEDLINE, and EMBASE from inception to 6 November 2013 for the original review and from January 2013 to 21 December 2015 for this update. We also searched the reference lists of retrieved studies and reviews, and two online clinical trial registries. This update differs from the earlier review in that we have included studies using oxycodone in combination with naloxone, and oxycodone used as add-on treatment to stable, but inadequate, treatment with another class of drug.
We included randomised, double-blind studies of two weeks' duration or longer, comparing any dose or formulation of oxycodone with placebo or another active treatment in chronic neuropathic pain.
Two review authors independently searched for studies, extracted efficacy and adverse event data, and examined issues of study quality and potential bias. Where pooled analysis was possible, we used dichotomous data to calculate risk ratio and numbers needed to treat for one additional event, using standard methods.We assessed the evidence using GRADE (Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation) and created a 'Summary of findings' table.
The updated searches identified one additional published study, and one clinical trial registry report. We included five studies reporting on 687 participants; 637 had painful diabetic neuropathy and 50 had postherpetic neuralgia. Two studies used a cross-over design and three used a parallel group design; all studies used a placebo comparator, although one study used an active placebo (benztropine). Modified-release oxycodone (oxycodone MR) was titrated to effect and tolerability. One study used a fixed dose combination of oxycodone MR and naloxone. Two studies added oxycodone therapy to ongoing, stable treatment with either pregabalin or gabapentin. All studies had one or more sources of potential major bias.No study reported the proportion of participants experiencing 'substantial benefit' (at least 50% pain relief or who were very much improved). Three studies (537 participants) in painful diabetic neuropathy reported outcomes equivalent to 'moderate benefit' (at least 30% pain relief or who were much or very much improved), which was experienced by 44% of participants with oxycodone and 27% with placebo (number needed to treat for one additional beneficial outcome (NNT) 5.7).All studies reported group mean pain scores at the end of treatment. Three studies reported a greater pain intensity reduction and better patient satisfaction with oxycodone MR alone than with placebo. There was a similar result in the study adding oxycodone MR to stable, ongoing gabapentin, but adding oxycodone MR plus naloxone to stable, ongoing pregabalin did not show any additional effect.More participants experienced adverse events with oxycodone MR alone (86%) than with placebo (63%); the number needed to treat for an additional harmful outcome (NNH) was 4.3. Serious adverse events (oxycodone 3.4%, placebo 7.0%) and adverse event withdrawals (oxycodone 11%, placebo 6.4%) were not significantly different between groups. Withdrawals due to lack of efficacy were less frequent with oxycodone MR (1.1%) than placebo (11%), with a number needed to treat to prevent one withdrawal of 10. The add-on studies reported similar results.We downgraded the quality of the evidence to very low for all outcomes, due to limitations in the study methods, heterogeneity in the pain condition and study methods, and sparse data.
AUTHORS' CONCLUSIONS: There was only very low quality evidence that oxycodone (as oxycodone MR) is of value in the treatment of painful diabetic neuropathy or postherpetic neuralgia. There was no evidence for other neuropathic pain conditions. Adverse events typical of opioids appeared to be common.
这是对一篇早期综述的更新,该综述曾同时考虑神经病理性疼痛和纤维肌痛(2014年第6期),现在已分为针对这两种病症的单独综述。本综述仅考虑神经病理性疼痛。包括羟考酮在内的阿片类药物常用于治疗神经病理性疼痛,一些专业人士认为其有效。大多数综述对所有阿片类药物进行了综合研究。本综述专门寻找了任何剂量、任何给药途径的羟考酮的证据。其他阿片类药物的研究则在单独的综述中进行。
评估羟考酮治疗成人慢性神经病理性疼痛的镇痛效果和不良事件。
我们检索了Cochrane对照试验中心注册库(CENTRAL)、MEDLINE和EMBASE,检索起始时间至2013年11月6日用于原始综述,更新检索时间为2013年1月至2015年12月21日。我们还检索了检索到的研究和综述的参考文献列表,以及两个在线临床试验注册库。本次更新与早期综述的不同之处在于,我们纳入了使用羟考酮联合纳洛酮的研究,以及将羟考酮作为另一类药物稳定但不足治疗的附加治疗的研究。
我们纳入了为期两周或更长时间的随机、双盲研究,比较任何剂量或剂型的羟考酮与安慰剂或其他活性治疗在慢性神经病理性疼痛中的疗效。
两名综述作者独立检索研究,提取疗效和不良事件数据,并检查研究质量和潜在偏倚问题。在可能进行汇总分析的情况下,我们使用二分法数据计算风险比和需治疗人数以获得一个额外事件,采用标准方法。我们使用GRADE(推荐分级评估、制定和评价)评估证据,并创建了一个“结果总结”表。
更新后的检索又识别出一项已发表研究和一份临床试验注册报告。我们纳入了五项研究,共687名参与者;其中637人患有疼痛性糖尿病神经病变,50人患有带状疱疹后神经痛。两项研究采用交叉设计,三项采用平行组设计;所有研究均使用安慰剂对照,尽管有一项研究使用了活性安慰剂(苯海索)。缓释羟考酮(oxycodone MR)根据疗效和耐受性进行滴定。一项研究使用了羟考酮MR与纳洛酮的固定剂量组合。两项研究在持续、稳定的普瑞巴林或加巴喷丁治疗基础上加用了羟考酮治疗。所有研究均存在一个或多个潜在的主要偏倚来源。没有研究报告经历“显著获益”(至少50%的疼痛缓解或有很大改善)的参与者比例。三项关于疼痛性糖尿病神经病变的研究(537名参与者)报告了相当于“中度获益”(至少30%的疼痛缓解或有较大或很大改善)的结果,接受羟考酮治疗的参与者中有44%达到该结果,接受安慰剂治疗的参与者中有27%达到该结果(获得一个额外有益结果的需治疗人数(NNT)为5.7)。所有研究均报告了治疗结束时的组平均疼痛评分。三项研究报告称,单独使用羟考酮MR比安慰剂能更大程度地降低疼痛强度,且患者满意度更高。在将羟考酮MR添加到持续、稳定的加巴喷丁治疗中的研究中也有类似结果,但在将羟考酮MR加纳洛酮添加到持续、稳定的普瑞巴林治疗中未显示出任何额外效果。单独使用羟考酮MR的参与者发生不良事件的比例(86%)高于安慰剂组(63%);发生一个额外有害结果的需治疗人数(NNH)为4.3。严重不良事件(羟考酮组3.4%,安慰剂组7.0%)和因不良事件退出研究的比例(羟考酮组11%,安慰剂组6.4%)在两组之间无显著差异。因疗效不佳而退出研究的情况在羟考酮MR组(1.1%)比安慰剂组(11%)更少,预防一次退出研究的需治疗人数为10。附加治疗的研究报告了类似结果。由于研究方法的局限性、疼痛状况和研究方法的异质性以及数据稀少,我们将所有结果的证据质量降级为极低。
仅有极低质量的证据表明羟考酮(作为羟考酮MR)在治疗疼痛性糖尿病神经病变或带状疱疹后神经痛方面有价值。对于其他神经病理性疼痛病症没有证据支持。阿片类药物典型的不良事件似乎很常见。