Albert Einstein College of Medicine, Bronx, New York.
Universidade Estadual de Maringá, Maringá, Paraná, Brazil.
Cancer Prev Res (Phila). 2019 Mar;12(3):159-170. doi: 10.1158/1940-6207.CAPR-18-0419. Epub 2019 Jan 16.
Most cervical cancers occur in women who do not participate in cervical-cancer screening. We therefore evaluated adherence to screening for clinic-based Pap testing, self-collected sampling for HPV testing, and choice of the 2 among 483 unscreened/underscreened women in Brazil. Three public Basic Health Units (BHU) were each randomly assigned to three arms: (i) Pap testing at the BHU ( = 160), (ii) "Self&HPV" (self-collection for HPV testing) ( = 161), and (iii) "Choice" between self-collection and HPV testing and Pap test at the local BHU ( = 162). The theory-based (PEN-3 and Health Belief Model) intervention in all three arms was implemented by trained Community Health Workers (CHW) at participants' home. With the first invitation, 60.0% in the Pap arm, 95.1% [154 of 161 (95.7%) who selected Self&HPV and 0 of 1 (0.0%) who selected Pap] in the Choice arm, and 100% in the Self&HPV arm completed screening. By the second invitation to choose a method of screening in the Choice arm, 100% completed screening. After three invitations, 75.0% of women in the Pap arm completed screening. Adherence to screening differed by study arm ( < 0.001). In conclusion, Self&HPV testing is a promising strategy for unscreened/underscreened women who are recalcitrant or unable to undergo clinic-based cervical screening to complement the screening modality used in the general population. In Brazil, where Pap testing is recommended for routine cervical screening, training CHWs in behavior change strategies and offering Self&HPV or Choice could greatly improve screening population coverage by reaching the unscreened/underscreened populations.
大多数宫颈癌发生在未参与宫颈癌筛查的女性中。因此,我们评估了巴西 483 名未筛查/筛查不足的女性中基于诊所的巴氏涂片检查、自我采集样本 HPV 检测、以及在这两种方法中选择的 2 种方法的筛查依从性。三个公共基础保健单位(BHU)分别随机分配到三个组:(i)BHU 巴氏涂片检查(=160);(ii)“自我和 HPV”(自我采集 HPV 检测样本)(=161);以及(iii)在自我采集和 HPV 检测以及 BHU 局部巴氏涂片检查之间进行选择(=162)。基于理论(PEN-3 和健康信念模型)的干预措施在所有三个组中均由经过培训的社区卫生工作者(CHW)在参与者家中实施。第一次邀请时,巴氏涂片组的 60.0%、选择“自我和 HPV”组的 95.1%[161 人中选择自我和 HPV 的 154 人(95.7%)和选择巴氏涂片的 0 人(0.0%)]和自我采集 HPV 检测组的 100%完成了筛查。在选择组的第二次邀请中选择筛查方法时,100%完成了筛查。三次邀请后,巴氏涂片组的 75.0%女性完成了筛查。筛查的依从性因研究组而异(<0.001)。总之,自我采集 HPV 检测对于不愿或无法接受基于诊所的宫颈癌筛查的未筛查/筛查不足的女性是一种有前途的策略,可以补充常规人群中使用的筛查方式。在巴西,巴氏涂片检查被推荐用于常规宫颈癌筛查,培训 CHW 进行行为改变策略,并提供自我采集 HPV 检测或选择可以通过覆盖未筛查/筛查不足的人群来大大提高筛查人群的覆盖率。