Mughini-Gras Lapo, Wijnen Lena, Pires Sara M, Benincà Elisa, Onstwedder Charlotte, Hald Tine, Franz Eelco, Bonacic Marinovic Axel
Institute for Risk Assessment Sciences (IRAS), https://ror.org/04pp8hn57Utrecht University, Utrecht, The Netherlands.
Center for Infectious Disease Control, https://ror.org/01cesdt21National Institute for Public Health and the Environment (RIVM), Bilthoven, The Netherlands.
Epidemiol Infect. 2025 Jul 1;153:e77. doi: 10.1017/S095026882510023X.
Case-control studies can provide attribution estimates of the likely sources of zoonotic pathogens. We applied a meta-analytical model within a Bayesian estimation framework to pool population attributable fractions (PAFs) from European case-control studies of sporadic campylobacteriosis and salmonellosis. The input data were obtained from two existing systematic reviews, supplemented with additional literature searches, covering the period 2000-2021. In total, 12 studies on providing data for 180 PAFs referring to 5983 cases and 13213 controls, and five studies on providing data for 75 PAFs referring to 2908 cases and 5913 controls, were included. All these studies were conducted in Western or Northern European countries. Both pathogens were estimated as being predominantly linked to food- and waterborne transmission, which explained nearly half of the cases, with being mainly attributable to poultry (meat), and to poultry (eggs and meat) and pig (meat), as specific foodborne exposures. When also considering contact with animals, around 60% of cases could be explained by the larger group of zoonotic transmission pathways. While environmental transmission was also sizeable (around 10%), about a quarter of cases could be explained by factors such as travel, underlying diseases/medicine use, person-to-person transmission and occupational exposure.
病例对照研究可以提供人畜共患病病原体可能来源的归因估计。我们在贝叶斯估计框架内应用了一种元分析模型,以汇总欧洲散发性弯曲菌病和沙门氏菌病病例对照研究中的人群归因分数(PAF)。输入数据来自两项现有的系统评价,并辅以额外的文献检索,涵盖2000年至2021年期间。总共纳入了12项关于 的研究,提供了180个PAF的数据,涉及5983例病例和13213名对照,以及5项关于 的研究,提供了75个PAF的数据,涉及2908例病例和5913名对照。所有这些研究均在西欧或北欧国家进行。两种病原体估计主要与食物和水传播有关,这解释了近一半的病例,其中 主要归因于家禽(肉),而 归因于家禽(蛋和肉)和猪(肉),作为特定的食源性暴露。当也考虑与动物接触时,大约60%的病例可以由更大的人畜共患病传播途径群体来解释。虽然环境传播也相当可观(约10%),但约四分之一的病例可以由旅行、基础疾病/药物使用、人际传播和职业暴露等因素来解释。