Stanczuk Grazyna A, Currie Heather, Baxter Gwen, Foster Adele, Gibson Lindsay, Graham Catriona, Cuschieri Kate
Department of Research and Development, Dumfries and Galloway Royal Infirmary, Dumfries, UK.
Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Dumfries and Galloway Royal Infirmary, Dumfries, UK.
J Clin Pathol. 2015 Jul;68(7):567-70. doi: 10.1136/jclinpath-2014-202851. Epub 2015 Apr 15.
To assess the performance of a clinically validated human papillomavirus (HPV) test (the Cobas 4800 HPV test) in urine and self-taken vaginal specimens within a colposcopy population and to assess HPV prevalence before and after treatment across the different biospecimens.
A total of 100 women attending a colposcopy clinic provided three biospecimens (a clinician-taken liquid-based cytology sample (LBC), a self-taken vaginal sample and a urine sample) for HPV testing. HPV prevalence and concordance was compared across the biospecimens and clinical performance relative to the detection of cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN)2+ and CIN3+ was assessed. A total of 39 women retuned at 6 months for a post-treatment follow-up appointment, and HPV concordance in all biospecimens was measured relative to their original HPV status.
65 cases of CIN2+ were detected in the baseline population; sensitivity for CIN2+ was 92% (82 to 97) for the vaginal and the LBC sample and 80.0 (68% to 88%) for the urine sample. In the follow-up (post treatment) population, women were twice as likely to be HPV positive in their urine or vaginal sample compared with the equivalent LBC sample.
Vaginal and LBC samples showed very similar performance for the detection of CIN2+ in this population using the Cobas HPV test; further validation of these findings in screening contexts will be of value. Self-taken samples may have less utility in a 'test of cure' setting-given the higher prevalence of HPV relative to LBC.
评估一种经过临床验证的人乳头瘤病毒(HPV)检测方法(Cobas 4800 HPV检测)在阴道镜检查人群的尿液和自行采集的阴道标本中的性能,并评估不同生物标本在治疗前后的HPV流行率。
共有100名前往阴道镜检查诊所的女性提供了三种生物标本(临床医生采集的液基细胞学样本(LBC)、自行采集的阴道样本和尿液样本)用于HPV检测。比较了不同生物标本的HPV流行率和一致性,并评估了相对于宫颈上皮内瘤变(CIN)2+和CIN3+检测的临床性能。共有39名女性在6个月后返回进行治疗后随访预约,并根据其原始HPV状态测量了所有生物标本中的HPV一致性。
在基线人群中检测到65例CIN2+;阴道样本和LBC样本对CIN2+的敏感性为92%(82%至97%),尿液样本为80.0%(68%至88%)。在随访(治疗后)人群中,与相应的LBC样本相比,女性尿液或阴道样本中HPV呈阳性的可能性是其两倍。
在该人群中,使用Cobas HPV检测方法,阴道样本和LBC样本在检测CIN2+方面表现出非常相似的性能;在筛查背景下对这些结果进行进一步验证将具有价值。鉴于相对于LBC样本,HPV在自行采集样本中的流行率较高,因此自行采集的样本在“治愈检测”环境中的实用性可能较低。