Ji Xinlei, Zhao Jiahui, Fan Lejia, Li Huanhuan, Lin Pan, Zhang Panwen, Fang Shulin, Law Samuel, Yao Shuqiao, Wang Xiang
Medical Psychological Center, The Second Xiangya Hospital, Central South University, Changsha, Hunan, China.
Department of Psychology, Renmin University of China, Beijing, China.
J Clin Psychol. 2022 Apr;78(4):671-691. doi: 10.1002/jclp.23246. Epub 2021 Sep 20.
Predicting suicide is notoriously difficult and complex, but a serious public health issue. An innovative approach utilizing machine learning (ML) that incorporates features of psychological mechanisms and decision-making characteristics related to suicidality could create an improved model for identifying suicide risk in patients with major depressive disorder (MDD).
Forty-four patients with MDD and past suicide attempts (MDD_SA, N = 44); 48 patients with MDD but without past suicide attempts (MDD_NS, N = 48-42 of whom with suicide ideation [MDD_SI, N = 42]), and healthy controls (HCs, N = 51) completed seven psychometric assessments including the Three-dimensional Psychological Pain Scale (TDPPS), and one behavioral assessment, the Balloon Analogue Risk Task (BART). Descriptive statistics, group comparisons, logistic regressions, and ML were used to explore and compare the groups and generate predictors of suicidal acts.
MDD_SA and MDD_NS differed in TDPPS total score, pain arousal and avoidance subscale scores, suicidal ideation scores, and relevant decision-making indicators in BART. Logistic regression tests linked suicide attempts to psychological pain avoidance and a risk decision-making indicator. The resultant key ML model distinguished MDD_SA/MDD_NS with 88.2% accuracy. The model could also distinguish MDD_SA/MDD_SI with 81.25% accuracy. The ML model using hopelessness could classify MDD_SI/HC with 94.4% accuracy.
ML analyses showed that motivation to avoid intolerable psychological pain, coupled with impaired decision-making bias toward under-valuing life's worth are highly predictive of suicide attempts. Analyses also demonstrated that suicidal ideation and attempts differed in potential mechanisms, as suicidal ideation was more related to hopelessness. ML algorithms show useful promises as a predictive instrument.
预测自杀是出了名的困难和复杂,但却是一个严重的公共卫生问题。一种利用机器学习(ML)的创新方法,结合了与自杀倾向相关的心理机制和决策特征,可能会创建一个改进的模型,用于识别重度抑郁症(MDD)患者的自杀风险。
44名有过自杀未遂史的MDD患者(MDD_SA,N = 44);48名无自杀未遂史的MDD患者(MDD_NS,N = 48,其中42名有自杀意念[MDD_SI,N = 42]),以及健康对照组(HCs,N = 51)完成了七项心理测量评估,包括三维心理疼痛量表(TDPPS),以及一项行为评估,即气球模拟风险任务(BART)。描述性统计、组间比较、逻辑回归和机器学习被用于探索和比较各组,并生成自杀行为的预测因子。
MDD_SA组和MDD_NS组在TDPPS总分、疼痛唤起和回避子量表得分、自杀意念得分以及BART中的相关决策指标方面存在差异。逻辑回归测试将自杀未遂与心理疼痛回避和风险决策指标联系起来。由此产生的关键机器学习模型以88.2%的准确率区分了MDD_SA/MDD_NS组。该模型还能以81.25%的准确率区分MDD_SA/MDD_SI组。使用绝望感的机器学习模型能够以94.4%的准确率区分MDD_SI/HC组。
机器学习分析表明,避免无法忍受的心理疼痛的动机,以及对生命价值评估不足的决策偏差受损,对自杀未遂具有高度预测性。分析还表明,自杀意念和自杀未遂在潜在机制上存在差异,因为自杀意念与绝望感的关系更为密切。机器学习算法作为一种预测工具显示出有用的前景。