Toye Francine, Seers Kate, Barker Karen
Nuffield Orthopaedic Centre, Oxford University Hospitals NHS Trust, UK.
J Adv Nurs. 2014 Dec;70(12):2713-27. doi: 10.1111/jan.12485. Epub 2014 Aug 1.
To review systematically and integrate the findings of qualitative research to increase our understanding of patients' experiences of chronic pelvic pain.
Chronic pelvic pain is a prevalent pain condition with a high disease burden for men and women. Its multifactorial nature makes it challenging for clinicians and patients.
Synthesis of qualitative research using meta-ethnography.
Five electronic bibliographic databases from inception until March 2014 supplemented by citation tracking. Of 488 papers retrieved, 32 met the review aim.
Central to meta-ethnography is identifying 'concepts' and developing a conceptual model through constant comparison. Concepts are the primary data of meta-ethnography. Two team members read each paper to identify and collaboratively describe the concepts. We next compared concepts across studies and organized them into categories with shared meaning. Finally, we developed a conceptual model, or line of argument, to explain the conceptual categories.
Our findings incorporate the following categories into a conceptual model: relentless and overwhelming pain; threat to self; unpredictability, struggle to construct pain as normal or pathological; a culture of secrecy; validation by diagnosis; ambiguous experience of health care; elevation of experiential knowledge and embodiment of knowledge through a community.
The innovation of our model is to demonstrate, for the first time, the central struggle to construct 'pathological' vs. 'normal' chronic pelvic pain, a struggle that is exacerbated by a culture of secrecy. More research is needed to explore men's experience and to compare this with women's experience.
系统回顾并整合定性研究的结果,以增进我们对慢性盆腔疼痛患者经历的理解。
慢性盆腔疼痛是一种普遍的疼痛病症,对男性和女性都有很高的疾病负担。其多因素性质给临床医生和患者带来了挑战。
采用元民族志法对定性研究进行综合分析。
五个电子文献数据库,涵盖从建库至2014年3月的数据,并辅以引文跟踪。在检索到的488篇论文中,32篇符合综述目的。
元民族志的核心是识别“概念”,并通过持续比较构建概念模型。概念是元民族志的主要数据。两名团队成员阅读每篇论文以识别并共同描述概念。接下来,我们对各项研究中的概念进行比较,并将它们组织成具有共同意义的类别。最后,我们构建了一个概念模型或论证思路来解释这些概念类别。
我们的研究结果将以下类别纳入一个概念模型:持续且难以承受的疼痛;对自我的威胁;不可预测性,难以将疼痛界定为正常或病理性;保密文化;通过诊断得到确认;医疗保健体验模糊;经验知识的提升以及通过社群实现知识的体现。
我们模型的创新之处在于首次展示了构建“病理性”与“正常”慢性盆腔疼痛的核心斗争,而保密文化加剧了这一斗争。需要更多研究来探索男性的经历,并与女性的经历进行比较。